From Chuck Todd, Mark Murray, Domenico Montanaro, and Ali Weinberg
*** Bowing to Lieberman: As Joe Lieberman has now proved in this health-care debate, any U.S. senator can be a king. The question is whether that power is used in good faith to make the legislation better, or whether it's used for another reason. Last night, according to multiple reports, Senate Democrats appeared ready to drop the Medicare "buy-in" compromise that Lieberman said he objected. "Democrats aren't going to let the American people down," Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid said after the meeting, per the AP. "We all stand shoulder-to-shoulder." At 1:40 pm ET, President Obama invites the entire Democratic caucus -- including Lieberman -- to the White House to discuss health care, and the message he'll relay is essentially this, NBC's Savannah Guthrie reports: It's now or never to pass health reform. The White House wants the Senate to pass its bill before the Christmas holiday. After today's closed-door meeting, Obama will make a statement to the press at 3:00 pm ET.
*** Principle or Politics? There's now growing evidence that Lieberman's objection to the Medicare "buy-in" compromise isn't necessarily based on principle. Yesterday, a video from this past September made the rounds that showed Lieberman clearly stating he supports expanding Medicare to those in their 50s. In addition, while Lieberman has been a hawk on national security issues, he's been a consistent liberal on economic ones. According to National Journal's vote ratings for 2008, he was MORE LIBERAL than 68% of the Senate on economic issues, putting him squarely in the Democratic mainstream. (By comparison, he was more liberal than just 38% of the chamber on foreign affairs, placing him to the right of the Dem caucus.) In 2007, he was more liberal than 72% of the Senate on the economy, and his ratings for 2005 and 2006 were similar. Bottom line: It appears Lieberman is acting a bit out of character on this issue, given his history of being a rank-and-file Democrat (leaning liberal/progressive) on domestic issues. This is why the charge of playing politics with the left is looking so believable to some.
*** Time for SNL's "The Rock" Obama? If there is one thing that both yesterday's meeting with the bankers and today's meeting with Senate Democrats have in common, it's that they're situations where some might argue that it's time for the cool, calm, collected Obama to, well, lose his cool a bit. Of course, it's only worth getting angry if you can follow it up with a tangible punishment. What's the tangible punishment, for instance, with Lieberman? The Democrats and the White House have no margin of error on health care; they just don't have the handful of Republicans they need to simply ignore Lieberman or Nebraska's Ben Nelson. It certainly appears that Lieberman is getting everything he wants, which is causing a HUGE revolt of sorts on the left. Last night, one of the more influential progressive activists, Markos Moulitsas, Tweeted: "Insurance companies win. Time to kill this monstrosity coming out of the Senate." What's left besides the mandate, he and others argue, if public option and a Medicare buy-in are both gone. Of course, the White House and others would argue that expanded health-care coverage for millions of Americans, as well as new restrictions on health insurers, is significant reform. But the White House needs to sell that -- especially to its left flank. By the way, where is Olympia Snowe in all of this?
*** Gitmo detainees get new home: Besides health care, the other big news today is the report that the federal government will acquire the Thomson Correctional Center in Thomson, IL to house a limited number of Gitmo detainees. According to the AP, Illinois Gov. Pat Quinn and Sen. Dick Durbin are set to make the announcement today at the White House with administration officials. "The facility in Thomson had emerged as a clear front-runner after Illinois officials, led by Durbin, enthusiastically embraced the idea of turning a near-dormant prison over to federal officials." Of course, the politics of relocating Gitmo detainees to the United States has been incredibly tricky. But we guess the politics becomes a bit easier when an economically ailing community like Thomson wants the business, and when the governor, both U.S. senators, and nearly the entire congressional delegation (13 of 19) are Democrats. Also, it doesn't hurt when the Democratic president hails from the state, either… He put it in HIS backyard.
*** DeMint-ed? Today, conservative activists are gathering on Capitol Hill to protest the health-care bill. It's similar to Michele Bachmann's "Super Bowl of Freedom," but this time the action is on the Senate side. Speaking at the event will be Laura Ingraham and GOP Sens. Tom Coburn and Jim DeMint. In fact, perhaps more than any other politician outside Palin and Bachman, DeMint has become the GOP politician most identified with the Tea Party movement. And DeMint has made his presence felt: He has endorsed conservative primary candidates (Marco Rubio, Chuck DeVore) running against more moderate/establishment opponents; he has set up his own PAC (the Senate Conservatives Fund); and is now being talked about a possible presidential candidate. Above all, he represents a strand of Republicanism that places ideology over victory. As he said earlier in the year after Arlen Specter switched parties, "I would rather have 30 Republicans in the Senate who really believe in principles of limited government, free markets, free people, than to have 60 that don't have a set of beliefs."
*** Unintended consequences: One recently retired REPUBLICAN senator blamed DeMint and his style -- not necessarily his ideology -- as a big contributor to the perceived breakdown of the Senate to get things done on hot-button issues like, say, immigration. Republicans in D.C. are no longer shunning DeMint even as some want to. Being out of power makes many a pragmatist, but what is the unintended consequence for Republicans if they do get a majority back in the House or Senate and if the new members come from a more purist conservative background?
*** Gordon gone in a flash: Yesterday, Bart Gordon of Tennessee became the fourth House Democrat in recent weeks to announce his retirement, following Dennis Moore of Kansas, John Tanner of Tennessee, and Brian Baird of Washington state. This fourth retirement is going to set off a mini-frenzy among political handicappers that this is how a wave begins. And it is: DCCC Chairman Chris Van Hollen tells the Washington Post that more retirements are coming, but he denied it was a "wave" or "flood" of retirements. On paper, both parties now have almost an equal number of competitive open seats. Yet if the Dem open-seat number climbs closer to 20, then suddenly the ingredients are there for Republicans not only to make the case for big 2010 gains -- but also to start laying out plausible scenarios that they can regain control of the House. It's still a stretch at this point. But as we've seen in previous "wave" or "change" elections in 2006 and 2008, nothing should be ruled out. At this point in the '06 cycle, it was laughable to suggest Democrats could take back the Senate.
*** Obama's (and Biden's) day: In addition to his health-care meeting with Senate Democrats, President Obama visits a Home Depot at 10:45 am ET in Alexandria, VA, where he'll discuss the economic impact of making energy-saving home retrofits. As for Vice President Biden, he made an appearance on "Morning Joe" earlier today, saying that the economic stimulus has "primed the pump." Later, he hosts a Recovery Act implementation meeting with the cabinet. Per a release, Biden "has delivered a progress report to President Obama on how the Recovery Act is helping build a cleaner, more energy-efficient economy by tapping homegrown sources of energy. In his memo to the president, the vice president reports on specific advances already underway as a result of the foundation the Administration has laid through the Recovery Act and other initiatives, and details how our economy will be transformed by these investments in the coming years."Â
*** Elsewhere today: John McCain gives a speech on Afghanistan at the conservative Heritage Foundation at 2:30 pm ET… U.S. Af/Pak envoy Richard Holbrooke speaks at the Council on Foreign Relations at 6:30 pm… And Secretary of State Clinton meets with an official from Serbia (2:45 pm), then the U.S. Ambassador to China Jon Huntsman (4:40 pm), and then heads to the White House for a National Security Council Principals Meeting (5:15 pm).
Countdown to MA Special Election: 35 days
Countdown to IL primary: 49 days
Countdown to TX primary: 77 days
Countdown to Election Day 2010: 322 days
Click here to sign up for First Read emails.
Text FIRST to 622639, to sign up for First Read alerts to your mobile phone.
Check us out on Facebook and also on Twitter.Â