The Supreme Court will decide whether or not to scale back the landmark Voting Rights Act, which requires states with a history of discrimination at the polls to get federal permission before making any changes in how they conduct elections. NBC's Pete Williams reports.
Agreeing to hear another important case on race in America, the Supreme Court said Friday it will take up a battle over a key part of the landmark Voting Rights Act. Civil rights groups fear the court will use this case to gut the law.
Passed by Congress in 1965 and renewed four times since then, most recently in 2006, a key provision requires states with a history of discrimination at the polls to get federal permission before making any changes to election procedures -- from redrawing congressional district boundaries to changing the locations of polling places.
The law was at the core of the legal cases this year blocking strict new voter ID laws in Texas and South Carolina.
Shelby County, Ala., claims the pre-clearance requirement -- which currently covers nine entire states, 12 cities and 57 counties elsewhere -- is unconstitutional. Under the law, those states and areas are presumed to be acting improperly whenever they seek election changes and "must either go hat in hand to Justice Department officialdom to seek approval, or embark on expensive litigation in a remote judicial venue," says the lawyer for the county.
The areas covered by the law, Shelby County says, include some localities that have made substantial reforms while missing other parts of the country that have failed to root out discrimination at the polls. "Florida has been forced into pre-clearance litigation to prove that reducing early voting from 14 days to 8 is not discriminatory, when states such as Connecticut, Rhode Island, and Pennsylvania have no early voting at all," the county says.
But the NAACP Legal Defense and Education Fund says the current map is a close enough fit to cover the areas of greatest concern. "Congress is not a surgeon with a scalpel when it acts to legislate across the 50 states. But it can reasonably attack discrimination where it finds it," the group says.
Three years ago, the Supreme Court narrowly rejected a challenge to the pre-clearance requirement but strongly suggested that several justices had doubts about its constitutionality, given recent electoral reforms. "Things have changed in the South," the court said in 2009. "Blatantly discriminatory evasions of federal decrees are rare."
Last month, the Supreme Court heard another racially charged case, re-examining whether the nation's colleges can use affirmative action in admissions.


Question:
If you do not KNOW for sure WHO is actually voting because you have no ID requirement, how on Earh can you prove or disprove that there is or is no fraud?
still waiting for your answer above
well elvis since the 1930s criminals and criminal organizations have become much more advanced in the the ways they carry out there acts of fraud and theft. thus making many more laws required today than in the 1930s.
Try forming a coherent question and maybe someone will deign to enlighten you, Elvis.
Although, admittedly, THAT would be a complete waste of time.
your right on that....like a big mafia..government..but legal now
It is interesting to me that on election day the bars and liquor stores are closed but for early voting you can get as drunk as you want..........and it is laughable that illeagle aliens won't vote because it is illeagle since they already broke the law to be here
thats correct
voter fraud my azz...control is what you tea nuts want for life
the tea party...are the scribes and Pharisees of our time
and the elvis payne's are the donkeys of america,dumber then a stick, did your parents have any kids with brains cause i think you were born without brains
why yes there mad scientist...your smart to someone hahahahahaha.but who
Voting laws, at least for national elections, need to be standardized for the entire country. What types of ID, if any, need to be standardized for the whole country, voters with a long history of voting need to receive real assistance (not just instructions to go to a new line) in obtaining such ID's or they need to be grandfathered into the system. Voter IDs need to be issued at the time of registration and the law in effect at the time they register needs to be honored for all people who registered under it. Changes should not be backdated. Early and absentee voting needs to be standardized nationally and election day needs to be a paid holiday. Voting is by far more important and more basic to our country than all those other holidays we get to take off.
If voting is such an important right, and supported by the Constitution, and the right to bear arms is also an important right, and supported by the Constitution, why would you have to produce ID for one and not the other????? If you support NO ID to vote, you are merely a hypocrite if you don't ALSO support no ID to purchase, register, or own a gun!
funny the poor don't own a gun..some state's you cant have one..get it..the nation is not all like Texas
Elvis, owning a gun is a Constitutional right, just like voting. If you don't have to show ID to vote, why should you have to show ID to own a gun? And there are alot of poor people who DO own guns, Elvis. Just look at all the shootings in Chicago---those murders aren't being committed by rich old white men, Elvis. They are being committed by porr, young black men for the most part!
You said it, so name me the states where it is illegal to own any type of gun, Elvis.
stolen guns yes..
elvis payne your stupid,every state you are allowed to own a gun,and the poor people own more then all of us combine
stolen yes and yes I agree you are a retard
Come on Elvis. Tell us ALL which states don't allow anyone to own a gun! You SAID it, now PROVE it. Or is it like all your other posts---a bunch of gibberish???
NY
It is extremely difficult to get a gun in NJ......obvious "suppression" of a Constitutional right!
THAT is an out-an-out LIE Elvis. YOU most certainly CAN own a gun in New York state!!! Where did you learn to research ANYTHING before popping off?
hey stupid elvis,i have hunted in every state except hawaii and everyperson i was with all had guns so get your BS right
sorry there fella...they have gun control
read what hope said....oh so now Obama is for people owning guns....hahahahahaha..this cant get any better
Wow, Elvis, do you REALLY not understand the difference between "extremely difficult" and "illegal"?
again elvis get your crap straight,hawaii people have guns there just dont know if there is anything to hunt.elivis your the most screwed up person ever on this site.and screwed up elvis,there is gun laws in every state there is
yes read down below you..hahahahaha
hey a— — hole liberals that is set on ruining this country with thier bedpartner obameee, trhere should be voter ID laws.the civil rights BS should be done,you alrready have a black and islam man in the white house or maybe you stinking liberals just want the minorities to take over the whole country and give them a state or maybe give them all the houses and everything that hard working people worked thier a— — 's off to get where they are by hard work,now that is a concept hard work.maybe you leaches should try hard work.we show id for everything on this planet and thier should be no exemptions,there is no differance between muslum brotherhood,liberals,obame,hitler,black panthers,van jones,george soros,musilini,stalin and more,all want and wanted to rule the world and ruin it
retard
no dink elvis your the retard
THAT, Elvis, is definitely the pot calling the kettle black!
why yes the pot is black..sorry you 2 will have to deal with it another 4 years...hahahaha
Still waiting, Elvis. What states have outlawed the possession and ownership of guns? See, you spout that complete nonsense, and then can't even back up your OWN silly statements!
NY
You LIE, ELVIS, YOU LIE!!!! It is certainly NOT illegal to own a gun in New York state! It would take you (well, a normal person, anywys) about 30 seconds to type in "New York Gun Laws" and discover the truth--which is you blatantly LIED!
elvis now you are really screwed in the head i live in NY,open up your mouth when you know what you are talking about you dumb a- -
read what hope said....oh so now Obama is for people owning guns....hahahahahaha..this cant get any better
I caught both of you in a trap...you now cant say obama is taking away guns now...hahahaha..you 2 want a banana now
Hey Elvis, I NEVER have said that Obama is taking away guns. But YOU DID say that it was illegal to own a gun in NY, which is nothing but a big lie from another crazy liberal!!!!!!!!!!!!
I would continue to have a battle of wits with you, but clearly you are only half-equipped, and I don't pick on people less fortunate than I!!!!!
hahahaha Obama supports guns..now hahahahahaa
elvis go back to your parents and sue them for not giving you any brains and brainless elvis i know every law in all 50 states pertaing to firearms and teach firearm saftey and hunting classes ,so really come back when you know what you are talking about
hey people reading this blog and y'all say I'm the dumb one...hahahahaha..I got em..they cant say Obama is taking there guns away any more...hahahahahaha..read there blog...look the dumb azz still has not read one of my blogs yet..so funny..@ i agree
Elvis, are you on some type of drug? Hope said that it was extremely difficult to get a gun in NJ. How does that make it illegal? And who said ANYTHING about Obama either supporting or not supporting gun rights?
What the question was is this:
If voting is a right gauranteed by the Constitution, and you don't believe that people shouldn't have to prove they are legal to vote, shouldn't the same reasoning be applied to owning a gun, another right gauranteed by the Constitution, without having to show ID?
And have you spent ANY time at all researching ANY gun laws before posting your lie that it is illegal to own a gun in NY?
come on more more tell me more ...hahahahaha..please tell me more of gun rights..that Obama supports..hahahahaha
sorry try and change the subject now..hahahaha
explain to me how in an election a muslim loses twice, and the electorial college still puts him in my whitehouse???? this illegal alien is a resident of kenya, self admittedly!!! and is still here???? the supreme court is as bunch of @!$%#s, and when the muslim puts his cohorts in there during this term it will get worse... you idiots that voted for the muslim are going to be very sorry for what yhou have done.. he will destroy the constitution, that has alresdy started with his bitch hillary meeting with the united nations to form a pact to take all american guns... do you have any idea what this will do???? the civilian gun ownership is the largest army in the world>>>> you eliminate this and you will be overrun by criminals, aliens, hispanics, muslims etc.. i am embarrased to be a part of this nation! ! ! !
who wants to change the constitution...you far right fake Christians that who
Elvis must have been in some kind of research group for drug use. Surely no person could be that stupid on their own without some help from drugs gone bad!
funny 2 of you could not even stop a man on drugs...so funny Obama supports gun now...hahahahaha
Easy one for you, Elvis.
Cite which law blocks all citizens from owning a gun in New York state.
Real easy for a person like you with all the facts at your fingertips, Elvis.
Can you do that ONE very simple thing to back up your bold-faced lies?
Just give me the name, number, and when the law was passed, Elvis.
I lied...don't you get it..to catch your lies..about obama..taking away peoples guns..yes the tea party's mojo..yes you
my oh my..
Show me ONE single time I have said anything about Obama taking away guns or gun rights. In fact, just show me somthing I wrote that even HINTED at Obama doing ANYTHING of the sort, Elvis.
You are one seriously messed up dude, Elvis! I really feel sorry for you.
Thank God you live in Texas, where at the very least your vote is cancelled out by someone with the ability to think.
My oh my...........................................
so yes i do live in Texas...thanks for keeping up with me....yes your party and you when the subject came up..told the nation Obama was taking guns away.....remember..then people started buying guns...just like this last election
oh and not only guns but food...I wounder if y'all can get a refund back from the food yall bought from Glenn Beck
It sounds like the Supreme Court wants to legislate from the bench.
what happen folks you going to let a drug infested liberal take over the vine ..hahjahahaha
Democrats must sue to get the newly gerrymandered districts in many states overturned. THAT has become a bigger election scandal than any other.
Democrats garnered more votes for Congressional seats than the hate-and-fear mobsters, yet the gangsters control Congress?
Well, the goper gangsters have been warning us about voter fraud for years, and STILL managed to get away with it.
yes they were asleep at the wheel..they also sleep during local elections we need to tell people local elections are just as important
You should be required to show some type of photo idea to photo. How can we think voting is fair without some type of fair process? You should also be a (legal) citizen of the US, why allow people to vote but not pay taxes? Any person caught cheating or attempting to vote more than once should be band from the voting process. We all need driver license to drive a vehicle but not vote? Goes to show how messed up this country really is that we cant come up with a fair process for all people and all states. Look at ACORN, The Black Panthers and others who ever time election roll around they are caught cheating.
I live in Massachusetts and you only need to give your name and address to vote. No signature or ID. No chance for fraud there..........
It's official....the dead overwhelmingly voted for Obama this year!! Odd...I didn't see that many Obama bumper stickers on tombstones?
A Mississippi NAACP executive is in jail after being convicted of voter fraud for fraudulently casting absentee ballots, including four for dead people.
Lessadolla Sowers, who is a member of the Tunica County NAACP Executive Committee, was convicted and sentenced in April for what a judge said were crimes that cut “against the fabric of our free society.”
She was given a five-year sentence for each of the ten counts of voter fraud for which she was convicted, but the sentencing judge allowed her to serve the terms concurrently, according to the Tunica Times.
Matthew Vadum, author of Subversion, Inc., notes Sowers’s DNA was found on the inner seals of five envelopes that contained the absentee ballots, and liberal groups like the NAACP and ACORN have had a history of such shenanigans.
According to Vadum, the NAACP National Voter Fund has done everything from registering a dead man to vote in Ohio in 2004 to filling out fraudulent voter registration cards. In addition, ACORN, the community-organizing group Andrew Breitbart and James O’Keefe exposed aiding actors posing as sex traffickers, has had at least 54 people employed by or directly associated with the group convicted of voter fraud. ACORN has also been banned from Ohio due to its fraudulent activities.
And while Democrats try to frame voter ID laws as racist and partisan, Vadum notes many prominent Democrats, such as Minnesota Senator Amy Klobuchar, have successfully prosecuted people for voter fraud, which makes it more difficult for Democrats to argue that voter fraud does not exist and voter ID laws are not needed.
I am I to deduce from the opposition to voter ID laws that liberals in general, and minorities in particular are either too lazy, or too stupid, or both, to get IDs where required?
Hey Supreme Court, you didn't hesitate to go behind American's backs and sneakily decide that corporations are people did you, so what's stopping you now?
Yeah. That and The Obamacare decision. Are Unions people as well?
If I have to provide proof of health insurance for Obamacare, then ID for voting should be a no-brainer. On the other hand, I can choose not to vote, but the Gov is forcing me to purchase insurance.
Bob10-6414726
Your a idiot! plain and simple. I have a good idea set up all voting booths on military bases and you have to have a pass and id to get on the base to vote. Stops voter fraud and maybe the military will get to vote and have a say in the elections.
My proposal:
Get rid of Columbus Day and let's get out of the dark ages. Instead, let's have a holiday for voting - the Monday before the first Tuesday in November. Where to vote and where to turn in our mail in ballot? Drum roll....
The post office. Look: These guys are federal employees. They've taken an oath already. It's what they do!! Many post offices already have surveillance cameras. I say, give it to them. Everyone knows where the post office is located unless they are severely challenged. Many post offices have secure storage facilities to cram the votes in for safe keeping. Why not? Heck, they need the money and we need the security. Put the poll watchers there. Whatever. Just get er done. Maybe we should extend the holiday... to include the Friday and the Monday before Election Day Tuesday... don't want the post office employees to go postal on us. And with that kind of leeway, we should start seeing our numbers climb to 70 - 82% of eligible voters voting.
Our postal service is not perfect - nothing is. The point is, they handle mail everyday. They are federal. They can be set up for this with some modifications. This is better than the rat traps we are dealing with now... people standing in line for 6 - 8 hours. With the post office, all you have to do is stand in line for 5 hours... ha, just kidding...joke...
This Elvis character, a real person of interest. To some one! Hopefully someone will accept him or her as a person that can enjoy life and stop acting like a 6 year old child.
I bet you voted 3 times for Obama!
if i did it only would count as one dumb azz...oh your new on the vine..Elvis Payne is my real name get use to it..dummy
oh and if i were a child..you would not comment to a child right..are you a pedophile..let me help you in childish talk... bet you votes 3 times for Obama ..dumb azz..bet you did not
Three times Vince??? Some people had to fight just to get to vote once.
Some America we have become!!!
The following is from a report entitled The Voting Rights Act at Work 1982-2005 by The National Commission on the Voting Rights Act ...[This Commission was created by The Lawyers Committee for Civil Rights]
.
To read the complete report click> protecting minority voters - The Lawyers' Committee for Civil Rights ...
.
.
Although I am not against voter IDs, I was against them being pushed through right in front of the election..Time to work on that is now....As far as affirmative action, I wouldn't want it abolished, but the whole idea should be revisited ...as far as redistricting....I think that is always for the wrong reasons LOL
I agree with you, Ed.
Political Scientist Bernard Grofman, a noted expert on the Voting Rights Act
.
The above is from a report entitled The Voting Rights Act at Work 1982-2005 by The National Commission on the Voting Rights Act ...[This Commission was created by The Lawyers Committee for Civil Rights]
Affirmative Action needs to evolve to meet the needs of society today, as with any social policy. You won't see me arguing about that one. Does it need to be abolished? No. The inequities still exist and need to be addressed.
I also agree that timing was a huge issue with the voter ID. Difficult to convince people it was not engineered to suppress votes given the timing and the populations most affected.
On another thread, Clotho wrote-
.
.
Here is an excerpt from the U.S. Dept. of Education guidance--
Here is the link to the above "Guidance" --
click> "Guidance issued jointly by the Departments of Education and Justice