Romney: No regrets

Romney has an op-ed in USA Today, entitled, “Romney: I'll deliver recovery, not dependency.” Romney doesn’t express a hint of regret in his comments about 47 percent – or expressly comment on them at all. Instead, he says, “Since our founding, America has promoted personal responsibility, the dignity of work and the value of education. Those values made our nation the hope of the earth and our economy the envy of the world.”

And claims: “Government has a role to play here. Right now, our nation's citizens do need help from government. But it is a very different kind of help than what President Obama wants to provide.”

But USA Today’s editorial page counters with this (in a link that’s just below the first paragraph of Romney’s op-ed): “Romney's 47 percenters blur facts, message.” “[A]s is too often the case with the Republican presidential candidate, he muddles things up. He confuses the 47% who pay no income taxes with the 49% who get government benefits. And he conflates both groups with supporters of President Obama. In fact, the three groups overlap only in parts, like rings of the Olympic logo. Those who pay no federal income taxes are not made up exclusively of those Romney derides as dependent on government and lacking in personal responsibility. They include millions of senior citizens and low-skilled workers who consider themselves neither victims nor entitled to anything. …

“But what might be most troubling about Romney's strivers-vs.-moochers formulation is how he unnecessarily personalized a debate that should be about policy. Rather than criticizing a string of laws that has shielded too many adults from the obligation of paying federal income taxes, he disparages the non-payers themselves — apparently for the sin of complying with the law. That presents a rich irony, because Romney has defended his own low tax rates (of 14% on $21.6 million in 2010, much less than the top rate of 35%) by saying that he was fully in compliance with the law, and that Americans should pay only what's required.”

“Crisis communications experts from both sides of the aisle, as well as longtime Republican strategists, say Romney's comments that 47% of Americans would vote for President Obama because they are ‘dependent on the government’ and ‘believe that they are victims’ have been made worse by the campaign's clumsy response on a day when the goal was to get back on message,” USA Today writes.

Mark McKinnon: "The tape makes it harder to defend Romney and harder to support him.”

McKinnon in a column in the Daily Beast: “Mitt Romney is running out of time, and voters like me are running out of patience. I’ve been giving Romney the benefit of the doubt, assuming that at some point during this campaign he would reveal some things about himself that would give me some insight into who he really is and what drives him. And that I would be compelled to support him. … Well, the release of the Romney tape was a moment that certainly revealed something about him. But not what I was hoping for. Just the opposite. It reveals a deeply cynical man, who sees the country as completely divided, as two completely different sets of people, and who would likely govern in a way that would only further divide us.”  He also says Romney’s view is “a long way from the compassionate conservatism that welcomed more Americans into the Republican Party under President George W. Bush. … How can anyone support a candidate with this kind of a vision of the country?”

More: “[N]ow I honestly don’t know what Romney can do to win support from the voters he needs to gain a majority. I thought the debates would be an opportunity, but he has dug his hole so deeply now, I don’t know if he can pull himself out. Does he get up and say, ‘I was just kidding. I don’t see half of America as victims. I just needed to raise some money, and I got a little carried away talking to the 1 percent.’ I loved Michelle Obama’s line in her speech: ‘A presidency reveals who you are.’ So do campaigns. And mark me down as one Republican not happy with what is being revealed about Mitt Romney.”

“Mitt Romney painted an inaccurate portrait of the ‘47 percent of Americans [who] pay no income tax,’” the Boston Globe writes, adding, “Romney’s statistic accurately approximates the percentage of US households that do not pay federal income taxes. But he went on to suggest that this 47 percent relies on government help and refuses to ‘take personal responsibility’ — an assertion that ignores the fact that most of these households pay payroll taxes for Social Security and Medicare and some are service members in combat zones. … And contrary to Romney’s assertion that these are ‘people who will vote for the president no matter what,’ many Americans who pay no federal income taxes are members of important Republican voting blocs — including seniors and residents of the Bible Belt.”

Here’s a Boston Globe graphic of who pays what and where they live.

“Romney several times on Tuesday referenced a 1998 video clip that surfaced just before his Fox interview, which shows Obama, then an Illinois state senator, advocating for helping the poor through ‘redistribution,’” the Boston Globe writes. “ ‘The trick is figuring out how do we structure government systems that pool resources and hence facilitate some redistribution,’ Obama says in the clip, to which the conservative website the Drudge Report posted a link. ‘Because I actually­ believe in redistribution — at least at a certain level to make sure that everybody’s got a shot.’”

AP: “Who says Mitt Romney doesn't worry much about the very poor? That he believes corporations are people, too? That his wife drives two Cadillacs? Romney himself, that's who. When it comes to portraying the Republican nominee as an uncaring, out-of-touch rich guy, he's his own worst enemy, offering up a bonanza for Democratic attack ads.”

First, it was Linda McMahon (R-CT) separating herself from Romney, now another Northeastern Republican running for the Senate is, too. Scott Brown: "That's not the way I view the world," the GOP senator said in a statement. "As someone who grew up in tough circumstances, I know that being on public assistance is not a spot that anyone wants to be in."

The Boston Globe points out about Brown: that he “shares top political strategists with Romney.”

“Mitt Romney's secretly taped comments that Middle East peace ‘is almost unthinkable’ and that the Palestinians have ‘no interest whatsoever’ in peace are also drawing criticism from the White House,” USA Today writes.

“Romney’s remark triggered rebukes from Palestinian leaders, and the video overall continued to reverberate across the political world,” the Boston Globe writes.

Discuss this post

What shocked me in the video was Romney's derisive tone describing the fact Americans feel entitled to healthcare.

Are we living in Victorian England? "please sir, may I have some more healthcare?"

A certain amount of entitlement is a sign you ascribe to middle class values. Americans feel entitled to clean water, entitled to good public education, entitled to freedom of speech, religion and assembly. It's what makes us great. Heck, some people feel entitled to buy automatic weapons and multi-round ammunition. In ridiculing Americans for expecting basic healthcare, Romney is downright unAmerican, if you ask me.

  • 4 votes
Reply#1 - Wed Sep 19, 2012 9:23 AM EDT

When you watch the video, you can see Rombot ooze obsequious treacle upon the masses of Mammonites.

For all their religiousity, they don't realize you can't serve two masters.

The political question is: Is this a bigger gaffe than Ford's "Poland is free of Soviet influence."?

Probably. Can anyone recall a bigger one?

Once again proving...

Rombot.Has.Nothing.

  • 4 votes
#1.1 - Wed Sep 19, 2012 9:50 AM EDT

The "Secret Tape" the Media Will Ignore: Obama Praises Redistribution, Talks About Propaganda.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ge3aGJfDSg4

Almost 200,000 views in less than 24 hours!

  • 2 votes
#1.2 - Wed Sep 19, 2012 10:12 AM EDT

harley chic The moosie troll is back. You tube now thats the place for news.

  • 3 votes
#1.3 - Wed Sep 19, 2012 10:22 AM EDT

youtube is probably more reliable than NBC, besides his own words in his own voice are...well, his own words ;)

NBC= No Barack Criticism and/or Nothing But Crap.

  • 1 vote
#1.4 - Wed Sep 19, 2012 10:29 AM EDT

Obama Praises Redistribution, Talks About Propaganda.

What's your point Harley Chic?

    #1.5 - Wed Sep 19, 2012 10:50 AM EDT

    harley chic,

    Guess what? no one is ignoring the 1998 video of then state senator Obama! It doesn't seem as bad when you don't stop it where the Romney camp does. Let the tape finish stupid... let the tape finish

      #1.6 - Thu Sep 20, 2012 11:14 AM EDT
      Reply

      "[A]s is too often the case with the Republican presidential candidate, he muddles things up. He confuses the 47% who pay no income taxes with the 49% who get government benefits. And he conflates both groups with supporters of President Obama. In fact, the three groups overlap only in parts, like rings of the Olympic logo. Those who pay no federal income taxes are not made up exclusively of those Romney derides as dependent on government and lacking in personal responsibility. They include millions of senior citizens and low-skilled workers who consider themselves neither victims nor entitled to anything. …

      We have heard the sound of doom for Mitt Romney: DUMB DA DUMB DUMB, DUMB DA DUMB DUMB DUMB

      • 5 votes
      Reply#2 - Wed Sep 19, 2012 9:24 AM EDT

      MIttens deplores "dependency." So show us your taxes, Mitty, and let us see how dependent you and Queen Ann are on the largess of the people you hate!

      • 7 votes
      Reply#3 - Wed Sep 19, 2012 9:24 AM EDT

      Mittens and his wannabe-queen are afraid. If they show us their tax returns, "It would just give you people ammunition against us."

      Well, Annie, you loaded the gun.

      Mitt is most likely among those he calls 'moochers', those who pay no federal income tax.

      Why do the Romneys remind me of King Louis XVI of France and his lovely wife Marie Antoinette? Do we all remember what happened to them?

      • 6 votes
      #3.1 - Wed Sep 19, 2012 9:34 AM EDT
      Reply

      stick a fork in romney, he's done.

      • 2 votes
      Reply#4 - Wed Sep 19, 2012 9:35 AM EDT

      He may be done for the republicans but he sure is working hard for the re-elect Obama team.

        #4.1 - Wed Sep 19, 2012 11:12 PM EDT
        Reply

        Well the really really really stupid thing is Mitt Romney is one of the ones that pays no income tax. So is he voting for Obama so he can keep suckling off of the government teet or what? Damn moocher!!! :D HAHAHAHA ROFLMAO!!

        • 5 votes
        Reply#5 - Wed Sep 19, 2012 9:36 AM EDT

        Romney thinks he is entitled to pay less than 15% so he is not going to buy into the cutting taxes argument because it doesn't apply to him. :P What a moron!!

        • 3 votes
        Reply#6 - Wed Sep 19, 2012 9:42 AM EDT

        If the margins in the polls I would agree, unfortunately,there are way more people who hate the President than like Romney, and hate is a powerful force. Watch the ads coming out, in addition, they will cheat and lie their way to try and win. Romney is not interested in ANY segment of the population, only in being President, using anyone or anything to achieve that goal. WE THE PEOPLE DO NOT COUNT to him.

        • 6 votes
        Reply#7 - Wed Sep 19, 2012 9:49 AM EDT

        Queen Ann: "It's OUR turn!!!" (Stomping her feet under the camera, I am sure.)

        • 3 votes
        #7.1 - Wed Sep 19, 2012 12:11 PM EDT

        You're right, Mamma...hate is a powerful force.

        But love can conquer hate. Truth is more powerful than a lie.

        The universe exists in the constant tug and pull of opposing forces. If hate ever becomes infinitesimally more powerful than love, if evil ever becomes the tiniest bit stronger than good, the universe will implode and we will no longer exist.

        Therefore, we must stoke the fires of goodness, truth and love. In the end we will prevail.

        OBAMA/BIDEN 2012

        • 1 vote
        #7.2 - Wed Sep 19, 2012 12:18 PM EDT

        Kaybee, that only works when people believe they are being lied too. The haters believe every lie that fox and rush tell them. that is their truth.

          #7.3 - Wed Sep 19, 2012 11:16 PM EDT
          Reply

          Romney has no regrets about anything. If he doesn't win the Presidency to bolster his ego, he will just go back to living a life of luxury. This man does not have a servants heart. He only wants to be President for his ego. Nothing else matters to him.

          • 2 votes
          Reply#8 - Wed Sep 19, 2012 10:49 AM EDT

          Why would Willard regret anything. He's walking away with millions of dollars of other people's money. The brain dead rich think they can buy this election so they give Willard millions of dollars, the average working Joe thinks Willard will make their lives better so they give him their hard earned money. In truth when the election is over Willard with all the donation money he's walked away with and sent overseas to his foreign bank accounts will be sitting in his mansion you built for him in Southern California laughing his ass off.

          • 2 votes
          Reply#9 - Wed Sep 19, 2012 10:58 AM EDT

          Romney is so derisive of "entitlement" yet he feels that he is entitled to be president.

          • 1 vote
          Reply#10 - Wed Sep 19, 2012 12:51 PM EDT

          Romney has an op-ed in USA Today, entitled, “Romney: I'll deliver recovery, not dependency.” Romney doesn’t express a hint of regret in his comments about 47 percent – or expressly comment on them at all. Instead, he says, “Since our founding, America has promoted personal responsibility, the dignity of work and the value of education. Those values made our nation the hope of the earth and our economy the envy of the world.”

          First of all we hear a lot of rhetoric from Romney but no plan on how he will deliver recovery.

          Much of the dependancy comes from jobs shipped over seas by people like Romney so how will that help? No track record of helping ordinary people only helping already rich people.

          Many Americans have lost their dignaty as they want decent jobs but none are to be found because theTRICKle down theory doesn't work. Especially when the jobs trickle to India, China, Vietnam, and Philippines.

          So by doing everything in one's power to cut spending on education along with other programs how does Mr. Romney support education as he says he does? The fact is he doesn't.

          Willard Mitt Romney is a sociopath. He will say and do anything to get what he wants and it doesn't matter who he stomps on to get there. He has no feelings one way or the other about people. He feels he is ENTITLED to be President; it's his turn.

          As more and more people start paying attention the worse Willard looks and the better chance we have of him NOT being POTUS. The debates should be interesting as Willard will either look like a deer in the headlights or make stupid remarks that will insult someone or show just how out of touch with reality he reallys is.

            Reply#11 - Wed Sep 19, 2012 1:09 PM EDT

            Willard Mitt Romney is a sociopath. He will say and do anything to get what he wants and it doesn't matter who he stomps on to get there. He has no feelings one way or the other about people. He feels he is ENTITLED to be President; it's his turn.

            I agree completely, Adler.

            Romney is an evil man, all dressed up to look nice. Everything about him is a lie.

            I just hope enough voters are able to see through him.

              Reply#12 - Wed Sep 19, 2012 2:31 PM EDT

              You could hear the glee in his voice as he described the girls at the slave labor appliance factory. I wager that his eyes sparkled at that moment.

                Reply#13 - Thu Sep 20, 2012 11:07 AM EDT
                You're in Easy Mode. If you prefer, you can use XHTML Mode instead.
                As a new user, you may notice a few temporary content restrictions. Click here for more info.