Medicare: Not about jobs right now

There’s so much on this issue, it deserves its own section.

This headline from Reuters might be the most important point: “Presidential campaign focus turns to Medicare, not jobs.”

“Mitt Romney’s presidential campaign is trying to stay on the offensive in the increasingly heated debate over the future of Medicare,” the AP writes. “Romney and his running mate, Wisconsin Rep. Paul Ryan, signaled Wednesday that they invite scrutiny of their plans for the health care program that affects tens of millions of seniors. Such a focus would thrust the budget proposal Ryan authored — which included a controversial measure to transform Medicare into a voucher-like system — into the center of the race for the White House… The debate comes as Romney’s campaign continues an effort to undermine one of Obama’s greatest campaign strengths, his personal likability, trying to portray the outwardly calm Obama as a man seething with animosity and power lust.”

“GOP presidential candidate Mitt Romney’s new promise to restore the Medicare cuts made by President Barack Obama’s health care overhaul law could backfire if he’s elected,” the AP adds. “The reason: Obama’s cuts also extended the life of Medicare’s giant trust fund, and by repealing them Romney would move the insolvency date of the program closer, toward the end of what would be his first term in office. Instead of running out of money in 2024, Medicare says its trust fund for inpatient care would go broke in 2016 without the cuts. That could leave a President Romney little political breathing room to finalize his own Medicare plan.”

Yet here’s how the campaign responded: ‘The idea that restoring funding to Medicare could somehow hasten its bankruptcy is on its face absurd,’’ said spokeswoman Andrea Saul.

USA Today tries to set the record straight on the Medicare plans: To hear President Obama's re-election campaign tell it, you would think Mitt Romney and Paul Ryan want to end Medicare immediately and give the money to millionaires. And to hear Romney and Ryan tell it, you'd think Obama wants to fleece Granny and Grandpa of $700 billion in Medicare benefits and use the cash to finance ‘Obamacare.’

The truth is nothing of the sort — but those charges may drown out the truth between now and Election Day.”

It notes that Ryan’s original plan could have been characterized as ending “Medicare as we know it,” but not anymore. “The original budget plan written by Ryan and passed by House Republicans would turn Medicare into a ‘premium support’ plan. Seniors would have a fixed government subsidy with which to purchase private insurance — but the new version of that plan includes an option to retain traditional Medicare coverage.” But it adds that Ryan’s plan would make Medicare more expensive for seniors, “because the money seniors would get to put toward their insurance would be capped, while medical costs would not.”

It also points out of Obama’s “cuts”: “There are no cuts in benefits, and, in fact, seniors have already seen preventive services, such as annual exams and cancer screenings, with no co-pays. Instead, the savings comes by decreasing provider payments.” And: “Ryan's plan would repeal the health care law but keep the $716 billion in savings in place.”

And what about Medicaid? “Mr. Ryan’s budget is tougher on Medicaid, the big state-federal insurance program for the poor, which currently picks up the tab for a much of the nursing-home care of the elderly,” the Wall Street Journal writes.

The Wall Street Journal: “Paul Ryan Ventures Into the Medicare Debate.” The Wisconsin congressman did not discuss his budget proposal, which would use government-funded premium vouchers to subsidize the cost of private insurance plans. And he did not offer a specific plan from the Republican ticket beyond saying that he and Mr. Romney would protect and strengthen Medicare for today’s seniors and the seniors of the future. Instead, he argued that a second Obama term would mean drastic cuts to Medicare.” That’s even though Ryan’s budget assumes the same cuts.

Reuters: “Republicans gambling in taking Medicare issue head-on.” “The danger, according to political analysts, is that elderly dislike for Ryan's plan could shave off as much as 5 percentage points of voter support from the Republican ticket in closely fought races in half a dozen swing states, including Florida, Ohio and Pennsylvania,” it writes. “Many Republican officials initially expressed misgivings about the Ryan pick. But a growing number now believe a powerful offensive could recast Medicare as a debate about President Barack Obama's unpopular healthcare reform law, a tactic that drew enough senior citizen support in 2010 to win a Republican majority in the U.S. House of Representatives.”

Discuss this post

Romney picked Ryan, the pick backfires badly on the GOP.

Seniors will come out in droves to vote for Obama, and GOP has just lost Florida, a key battleground state.

You reap what you sow. If the golden rule (common sense) doesn't rule the GOP, then karma (also common sense) will hit the GOP.

  • 3 votes
Reply#1 - Thu Aug 16, 2012 9:16 AM EDT

The phonies will switch back to the economy and jobs just as soon as dems make repubs look like the idiots they are on health care. This republican party we all have had to deal with the last decade is pure dog @!$%#. Voting for ANY republican at this point is voting for dog @!$%#. Truly, yet again, they have crossed the line with voter suppression. To many have died for our right to vote. I want this republican stain on our flag washed out and washed out good. VOTE damnit, and more importantly, get everyone you know to vote. This new GOP "IS" pure dog @!$%#! These people would not know honor if it were staring them straight in the face. Obviously there is not an honorable american bone in their collective bodies. They have become an ugly stain on every aspect of any americans life. They have GOT to be taught a lesson they will never forget.

  • 3 votes
#1.1 - Thu Aug 16, 2012 11:27 AM EDT

rockymtnroustabout, don't you mean elephant @!$%#? It piles higher and deeper and more fitting of their dogma. Their smelly policies and other such muck can be raked all they want but despite Karl Rove's nick name there will be no blossoms this time around.

    #1.2 - Thu Aug 16, 2012 5:55 PM EDT
    Reply

    Medicare should be our one payor national healthcare system. It works great and all could pay into it making sure it stays solvent. It is a cure all for this country. To he#$ with the health insurance companies. Citizens care about them as much as they care about their clients' health when they deny coverage. Again I hope President Obama entertains this idea in his second term.

    • 5 votes
    Reply#2 - Thu Aug 16, 2012 9:19 AM EDT

    Why is the media ignoring that Ryan voted for Bush Medicare Advantage. A plan that reduced Medicare's solvency. Without the Republican Medicare Advantage plan, Medicare would have enough money to last until 2030.

    Let the world know it was Ryan and Republicans who emptied the coffers for insurance handouts that did not improve the quality of care for seniors. It drained hundreds of billions of taxpayer money to Republican donors.

    • 2 votes
    Reply#3 - Thu Aug 16, 2012 10:05 AM EDT

    Privatize Medicare = benefits financial industry

    Privatize SS = benefits financial industry

    Medicare has extraordinarily low administrative costs. From the standpoint of administration alone, Ryan will lower the unemployment rate in the financial sector.

    • 1 vote
    #3.1 - Thu Aug 16, 2012 10:40 AM EDT
    Reply

    seniors, ourmedicare and social security are great programs and now the pubs are trying to take credit for strenghtening medicare, what a crock!

    if elected romney/ryan will destroy both programs for the sake of wall street getting their greedy hands on our monies along withh the health companies.

    this election is a fight for the american way of life, a life which provides protection and balance, and romney/ryan are the Dark Side!

    seniors, for the sake of yourself and the rest of us, pull the straight democrat lever and push the bums on the dark side out and let the light in.

    save social security and medicare for all to follow!

    • 1 vote
    Reply#4 - Thu Aug 16, 2012 10:13 AM EDT

    you mean kick the can down the road? Medicare won't stay solvent unless something is done. Neither will Social Security...

    • 1 vote
    #4.1 - Thu Aug 16, 2012 10:20 AM EDT

    I see you've bought into the republican talking point Dem4Freedom.

    • 1 vote
    #4.2 - Thu Aug 16, 2012 10:37 AM EDT
    Reply

    Where are Romneys tax returns. Until we see them, nothing else really matters.

    Why? Because until the tax returns are released, we don't know what kind of person Romney is.

    • 1 vote
    Reply#5 - Thu Aug 16, 2012 11:03 AM EDT

    We do know what kind of person Willard is. He's a lying, cheating, nasty CEO that will stab anybody in the back to get what he wants. See this is the real world of big business that Willard spent his life in. Back stabbing, lying, cheating, nasty scum.

    • 1 vote
    Reply#6 - Thu Aug 16, 2012 12:00 PM EDT

    The Ryan plan is to help insurance companies with their profits not to help Senior Citizens.

      Reply#7 - Thu Aug 16, 2012 12:50 PM EDT

      The Obama campaign is a study in someone trying to make something out of absolutely nothing.

      Obama has no successes, just failures from day one. Someone showed him how to spin anything, but he does it so much, his audience gets dizzy just tryinhg to keep up.

      Now the discussion has come full circle. He can't run on his record, and he is running out of silly spins.

      What a disgusting loser.

      Romney/Ryan 2012/2016

        Reply#8 - Thu Aug 16, 2012 12:50 PM EDT
        • EPA* for Romney's toxic tax returns

        *Evasive Political Action

          Reply#9 - Thu Aug 16, 2012 1:48 PM EDT

          Obama leaving office will be a huge relief for America.

          Kind of like passing gas. LOL

            Reply#10 - Thu Aug 16, 2012 3:06 PM EDT

            It may be in January 2017 when he hands the reins over to the next Democrat President. The relief, however will be his as he has had to work so hard to undo the mess from that screw up Georgie Bush.

              #10.1 - Thu Aug 16, 2012 5:59 PM EDT
              Reply

              So lets see the debate...sooner the better...Obama has a plan and it is in action now and Romney / Ryan have a plan that won't last to the next election HUH which would I take...

                Reply#11 - Thu Aug 16, 2012 4:13 PM EDT
                You're in Easy Mode. If you prefer, you can use XHTML Mode instead.
                As a new user, you may notice a few temporary content restrictions. Click here for more info.