Romney: It's a bird; it's a plane; it's a tax

Now it’s a tax? “Mitt Romney Wednesday reversed the position staked out by his own campaign just two days before and said the penalty levied against Americans who do not buy health insurance under President Obama’s health care overhaul is ‘a tax,’” the Boston Globe writes. Romney told CBS: “The majority of the court said it is a tax, therefore it is a tax. The majority has spoken. There is no way around that.”

And get this… “During a parade in Wolfeboro, NH, Romney was told by someone in the crowd that the health care penalty was a tax. ‘I agree,’ Romney replied.”

Newsweek/Daily Beast’s Tomasky: “After some tap dancing, Mitt Romney now says the individual mandate is a tax. Democrats should call his bluff and agree—it'll hurt Mitt far more than Obama.”

GOP 12: “Hogan Gidley, a former adviser for Rick Santorum's erstwhile presidential bid, tells Talking Points Memo that his boss tried to warn voters about Mitt Romney's difficulty with prosecuting the case against ObamaCare.” He said, “It’s a problem, I’m not going to lie.... Here we are a couple months into the general and you’re going, ‘Hey wait a minute, that Rick Santorum was right'."

CBN’s David Brody: “It makes you wonder if Rick Santorum was on to something when he said it would be a mistake to nominate Romney because it makes arguing the healthcare issue extremely difficult. You think President Obama will be ready with a few good one-liners for the fall debates? You betcha.”

Romney’s attempts to “clarify” or wiggle out of his position on the mandate reminds that back in October, George Will called Romney “the pretzel candidate.” Will hit him for “twists” on ethanol, TARP, and collective bargaining. Will wrote, “A straddle is not a political philosophy; it is what you do when you do not have one.” And he called him “a recidivist reviser of his principles.” Will concluded: “Has conservatism come so far, surmounting so many obstacles, to settle, at a moment of economic crisis, for this?”

Bermuda Shorts: AP: “For nearly 15 years, Republican presidential candidate Mitt Romney's financial portfolio has included an offshore company that remained invisible to voters as his political star rose. Based in Bermuda, Sankaty High Yield Asset Investors Ltd. was not listed on any of Romney's state or federal financial reports. The company is among several Romney holdings that have not been fully disclosed, including one that recently posted a $1.9 million earning - suggesting he could be wealthier than the nearly $250 million estimated by his campaign. The omissions were permitted by state and federal authorities overseeing Romney's ethics filings, and he has never been cited for failing to disclose information about his money. But Romney's limited disclosures deprive the public of an accurate depiction of his wealth and a clear understanding of how his assets are handled and taxed, according to experts in private equity, tax and campaign finance law.”

The Obama campaign, in pushing the story, said it “raises serious questions about whether Mitt Romney established a Bermuda corporation to avoid U.S. taxes and attempted to hide it from the public.” And it put out a web video entitled, “Do you have an offshore bank account?”

“President Obama’s re-election campaign pounced on recent reports about Mitt Romney’s offshore holdings as new details emerged about a Bermuda-based company that was omitted from multiple financial disclosure reports,” the New York Daily News writes.

And it dings him for his home in New Hampshire: “Mitt Romney’s week-long vacation at his opulent lakehouse has reinforced the common line of attack that he’s out of touch with the common voter — a controversy President Obama may be trying to avoid. … Yet whether he’s on a jet ski or not, Romney’s wealth — estimated at more than $250 million — made more uncomfortable headlines for him on Tuesday. The fortune, mostly made at Bain Capital, is largely held in a complex and opaque offshore network, including a Swiss bank account and in tax havens like Bermuda and the Cayman Islands, according to a Vanity Fair report. Also, his campaign must now distance itself from the CEO of Barclays, who stepped down from the British bank Tuesday amid an interest-rate fixing scandal.”

The Romney campaign for its part is hitting Obama for “broken promises.” “With no record to run on, no rationale for re-election, and no positive message – President Obama is on the defensive, trying to win back the support of skeptical voters in states like Ohio and Pennsylvania where he has failed to follow through on his promises on health care, unemployment, and spending,” the campaign writes in a morning email.

And it links to several not-so-positive headlines for the president as he makes his way through Ohio:

Cleveland Plain Dealer, “Democrats And Republicans See Challenges For President Barack Obama In Key Mahoning Valley”
Toledo Blade, “Obama Trip Recalls to GOP Biden Visit Four Years Earlier”
Cleveland Plain Dealer, Sen. Portman Op-Ed: “Obama's Policies Are Stifling The Recovery”
Toledo Blade, “GOP Governors In Maumee Before Obama Visit”
Cleveland Plain Dealer, “Romney Campaign To Rival Obama Bus Tour Through Ohio With Bobby Jindal And Tim Pawlenty.”

There’s also the Akron Beacon Journal front page: “High jobless rate expected for years.”
And the Cleveland Plain Dealer front page: “Romney’s Mahoning Valley opportunity.”
The Youngstown Vindicator: “Romney campaign to stop in Valley; GOP hopeful wants to stay a step ahead of Obama’s bus tour.”

Of course, on the other hand:

Sandusky Register flag on the background of an American flag and the president’s face: “Welcome, President Obama. Obama visits Sandusky today; public access limited.”
The Toledo Blade (with a smiling Obama): “China to face accusation of unfair trade. Complaint to world body affects Toledo-made SUVs.”
The Ravenna Record-Courier: “Aurora man wins contest, has lunch with Obama.”
The Dayton Daily News front page: “IT job demand brings six-figure salaries.”
Hamilton Journal News: “Demand for IT jobs boosting salaries.”

Discuss this post

Well let's just examine the hypocrisy of MSDNC. When pushing Obamacare into law, Obama and his minions called it a penalty. Then, when they went to argue the case before the Supreme Court, they argued it was a TAX. Then after John Roberts waved his magic wand, declaring it somehow as being "constitutional" (commerce clause for individual mandate invalid, but "tax" on that invalid mandate somehow as "valid") we have Nancy Pelosi and other high ranking Dems saying it's a penalty.

But then, MSNBC will go after Romney's confusion ...... LOL !

I hate to admit it, but I actually find the penalty argument more convincing, but this would simply mean that Chief Justice Roberts had the "mother of all brain cramps" and that his logic in declaring it constitutional ..... was ENTIRELY ILLOGICAL !

But somehow, MSNBC continues to ignore the flip-flopping of Democratic positions. Is it a penalty ? Is it a tax ?? NO !! It's Obamacare, the ever-changing, ever-morphing POS hesalth care legislation passed by hundreds of Democrats who voted for it WITHOUT READING what was in it !!

  • 1 vote
Reply#1 - Thu Jul 5, 2012 10:13 AM EDT

Romney: It's a bird; it's a plane; it's a tax

it's another Romney flip-flop

  • 4 votes
#1.1 - Thu Jul 5, 2012 10:24 AM EDT

jim-1455434

Well let's just examine the hypocrisy of MSDNC. When pushing Obamacare into law, Obama and his minions called it a penalty.

jim it is a penalty just like you get penilized for being single, not having children, not owning a house, and now not having a health insurance.

hey, if you have health insurance, you will not pay a penny. If you don't because you CHOOSE not to, then you get penilized for sticking those who do with a bill.

  • 2 votes
#1.2 - Thu Jul 5, 2012 10:28 AM EDT
Reply

Romney is Brilliant. he has put obama on the defensive and vulnerable to attack on either side of the argument. Now that the RNC is beating up obamacare as a tax, the dems will defend it as a penalty and as such would be unconstitutional.

  • 1 vote
Reply#2 - Thu Jul 5, 2012 10:19 AM EDT

Romney is Brilliant. he has put obama on the defensive and vulnerable to attack on either side of the argument.

Only a person who resides in the RW bubble believes this. The very same RW bubble that still talks about Bill Ayers and Rev. Wright and believes the stimulus created ZERO jobs.

Come join us back on earth.

  • 2 votes
#2.1 - Thu Jul 5, 2012 11:14 AM EDT

motherland1 - if you actually think Romney is brilliant, I have a fabulous bridge I'd just love to sell you!. Romney hasn't had a brilliant moment in his entire life. And, he looks more and more idiotic every day!

Obama/Biden 2012

  • 1 vote
#2.2 - Thu Jul 5, 2012 4:21 PM EDT
Reply

Who cares what they call it you have to pay it! Lawyers earn lots of money debating this and it only distracts from the content of the candidate's platforms.

  • 1 vote
Reply#3 - Thu Jul 5, 2012 10:24 AM EDT

Romney will make his mind up again tomorrow, and reverse it the next day. Details, commitments, and consistency elude him. Never invest your vote in a grab bag, you never know what you are going to get.

    Reply#4 - Thu Jul 5, 2012 1:13 PM EDT

    obama will eat Romney alive in upcoming debates.

      Reply#5 - Fri Jul 13, 2012 8:26 PM EDT

      Romney lies but does not have enough evidence to prove. he is going to lose big. he is not prepared when struck back.

        Reply#6 - Fri Jul 13, 2012 8:29 PM EDT

        I do not trust anyone who puts his dog on top of the car

          Reply#7 - Fri Jul 13, 2012 8:32 PM EDT
          You're in Easy Mode. If you prefer, you can use XHTML Mode instead.
          As a new user, you may notice a few temporary content restrictions. Click here for more info.