Another weak jobs report helps Romney get back on message … But Obama leads in Virginia and two words – gender gap. It’s tough to see a great path to 270 for Romney without winning Virginia. … Is McDonnell veep possibility hurt by good VA economy? … The 17 “Swing Markets” – Obama’s going to two of them this weekend … China became the political story yesterday … Romney and religion, the need to coalesce but reach out to swing voters … Santorum, Romney meet, but no endorsement expected today … Romney addresses Grennell … and Lugar’s last chance: the last big weekend of campaigning in Indiana. It’s statesmanship vs. the Tea Party (and the Tea Party’s winning).
NBC’s Chuck Todd, Domenico Montanaro, Natalie Cucchiara, and Brooke Brower

Jewel Samad / AFP - Getty Images
Republican presidential candidate Mitt Romney speaks during a campaign event in Chantilly, Virginia, on May 2, 2012.
*** Another weak jobs report helps Romney get back on message: The bin Laden anniversary, a secret trip to Afghanistan to announce staying in that country for 10 more years and simultaneously the ending of the war as we know it, a diplomatic crisis, a presidential candidate drops out, and the latest report on the most important number this election – unemployment. All in a week’s work. It was another weak jobs report. Just 115,000 jobs were added, though the unemployment rate dropped to 8.1 percent,” and CNBC notes that the rate dropped because there were fewer people in the workforce. It was clear in the last NBC/WSJ poll that economic optimism had flat-lined. These jobs reports do have an impact on how people view the economy. We noted earlier in the week that Romney was having a tough week because of all the national security news that dominated. This will allow him to get back on message for a month. “This is not progress. This is very, very disappointing,” Romney said this morning. The upside inside the report was the fact that job gains were revised UPWARD for BOTH February and March, accounting for SOME of the drop in unemployment. But again, the shrinking workforce is the story.
The Daily Rundown's Chuck Todd talks about the April jobs report, in which unemployment fell to 8.1 percent with the economy adding just 115,000 more jobs.
*** Obama leads in Virginia: With Romney in Virginia yesterday, the Washington Post is out with a poll poll in Virginia, where Obama leads 51%-44% over Romney. It’s the fifth swing state poll in two days – WI, FL, OH, PA, VA. What have we learned from those? Romney’s got a lot of work to do. The common denominator on all these – we thought he might get a bump after being the de facto nominee, and while he showed improvement in some places, particularly Florida, he didn’t get much of a bump out of becoming the nominee. Virginia may very well be the scariest state for Romney. If Obama wins Virginia, he could win the White House without FL or OH. If Romney loses Virginia, he doesn’t have a path if he also doesn’t win any of the swing states out West.
*** Virginia, not just for lovers, but also for candidates – but two words – gender gap: Assuming the West becomes out of reach due to the GOP’s problems with Hispanics, then Romney HAS to win one of the following four: PA, VA, WI, or MI. And of those four, Virginia is clearly the most winnable. And of all the swing states, Virginia’s was closest to the national number in 2008. And it has moved with where the country has moved from 2005 forward. “I think most would say it's a very tough path for a Republican to win the presidency without winning Virginia,” said Gov. Bob McDonnell, who appeared with Romney yesterday. “So that's why you see Mitt here last night, today and he'll be here next week a couple times. This is clearly on the top of his list. The president's here today and the president's here on Saturday, so everybody knows Virginia's in play.” Digging deeper into the Washington Post poll and one result stands out above all others: the gender gap. If you didn’t think before that the fight over transvaginal ultrasounds hurt the GOP, then simply look at this gender gap in this poll. That fight did damage to the GOP’s brand with suburban women.
*** The Swing Markets: There are swing states and then there are swing MARKETS inside those swing states. And it’s these swing markets, where you’ll not just see TV ad spending but the candidates themselves. Our ad-tracking partners, SMG Delta crunched the numbers to break down the 17 “swing markets” within the broader group of battleground states. These are the ONLY media markets in these 12 battleground states where Bush won in 2004 and Obama won in 2008. We break down the list of those places here. Interestingly, Virginia sports three of the 17 markets (including Richmond) and Ohio sports two of the 17 (including Columbus). And where’s the president going for his first two official campaign events on Saturday? Richmond, VA, and Columbus, OH. By the way, margins in media markets matter as much as whether a candidate carries it. For instance, Colorado does not have a “swing” market. Kerry and Obama BOTH won the Denver-market. Obama just won it by a MUCH larger margin.
*** China rising: We noted yesterday that the story of Chinese dissident Chen Guangcheng would become a political story, and did it ever – with Chen himself even calling into a Capitol Hill hearing. Romney criticized the Obama administration, charging that yesterday was “a day of shame for the Obama administration." Romney wasn’t very specific about would he’d do if he were president, but an aide indicated to NBCPolitics.com’s Mike O’Brien that Romney would have offered him asylum. State Department spokesman Mark Toner contended, however, “You cannot achieve political asylum unless you are outside of the country you are trying to flee.” This morning China says Chen can apply to study abroad, which seems like a way for everyone to save face. We can’t imagine Secretary Clinton leaving China without a firm deal in place.
*** Quick on the trigger: Romney rolled the dice a tad by deciding to jump on the Chen story. Yes he couched his comments with “If the media reports are true” but what if they aren’t. There’s a backstory here that no one is quite sure of. Why not wait a day? Why not wait two days until all the facts are known and the Secretary of State is back in the country? Of course, Republicans might argue that they put pressure on the administration to fight for Chen. This morning, Clinton, by the way, said, “All of our efforts with Mr. Chen have been guided by his choices and our values,” per NBC’s Sarah Blackwill. “And I'm pleased that today our ambassador has spoken with him, our embassy staff and our doctor had a chance to meet with him and he confirms he and his family now want to go the United States, so he can pursue his studies. In that regard, we are also encouraged by the official statement issued today by the Chinese government confirming that he can apply to travel abroad for this purpose.”
*** Close up: Romney was asked by local NBC Virginia affiliate WAVY if he believed his religion was part of the reason conservatives were slow to embrace him. Romney replied, “I've got great support from evangelical voters - a number of states that we had primaries in I was the leading contender.” Evangelicals were not a strength for Romney; it’s a big reason he lost South Carolina and didn’t win a single culturally Southern state. He won evangelicals in NH, MA, FL, NV, VT, MD, VA (where only he and Paul were on the ballot). He acknowledged, though, “I know there will be a narrative perhaps to that degree….” But he said, “I want all elements of our party to come together and support me, but I also have to get those folks that are the undecideds, the independent voters, women voters, Hispanic voters, young people, I've got to get them, too.” How tough has this pivot been for Romney? AP notes today that members of the Mormon Church are nervous about the church coming into the spotlight, having again to defend the church amidst “vetting” that “will take place amid the emotion of what may well be a nasty general election.”
*** McDonnell hurt by good VA economy ironically? McDonnell noted yesterday that Virginia has the lowest unemployment rate in the Southeast, and he’s running sunny ads about the state of the Virginia economy. If you’re wondering how he did in the audition, he might not make as much sense now, because he throws Romney off his “bad economy” message a bit. McDonnell would argue that it’s because of his pro-business policies that have helped create jobs in the state. But it’s hard to have it both ways. "Remember three and a half years ago, we heard that tune about hope and change?" McDonnell said. "Now what do we have? We have recession, division and malaise. It’s time for a change, don't you think?" But when you peel back the onion of the Virginia economy, you realize just how much the federal government is such a vital part of the economy. Two words: defense contractors.
*** Santorum, Romney meeting but not expected to appear together publicly: Romney will appear with Rick Santorum on his home turf in Pittsburgh today, but there isn’t expected to be an endorsement and, NBC’s Andrew Rafferty reports, the two aren’t even expected to appear together PUBLICLY. Santorum is really running out of political capital here – whatever’s left of it. Even Michele Bachmann, who once said Romney couldn’t beat Barack Obama, endorsed him yesterday. As AP’s Phil Elliott pointed out, Santorum endorsed Jon Bruning yesterday in the Nebraska Senate primary, but still hadn’t yet endorsed Romney. Romney holds an event at noon ET. The last time Pittsburgh hosted one of these meetings was for Bush-McCain.
*** Romney addresses Grennell – ‘wanted him to stay’: Mitt Romney address the Richard Grennell controversy for the first time this morning on FOX. “We wanted him to stay with our team,” he said, per NBC’s Garrett Haake. “He's a very accomplished spokesperson. We select people not based on ethnicity, gender, sexual orientation... We select based on ability.”
*** Big weekend of campaigning in IN and WI: It’s the last chance for Richard Lugar to turn the tide in his bid to retain his Senate seat against upstart Tea Party challenger Richard Mourdock, the state treasurer. Bloomberg today sums it up – pitting Lugar’s “statesmanship” against Mourdock’s fight for conservative purity. In Wisconsin, two Democrats – Kathleen Falk and Tom Barrett have their last chances to sell Democrats on why they would be best to take on the well-funded Gov. Scott Walker, in the recall fight. Barrett is favored by double-digits, according to a poll out Wednesday.
*** Get the NBC Politics app: Get the power of our political reporting and analysis where and when you want it with the new NBC Politics app. Get the latest stories and video from First Read, The Daily Rundown, Meet the Press, and more. Read our daily Tip Sheet to stay in-the-know with Decision 2012 and check out our national and state contest results. The app features an exclusive battleground map game that allows readers to carve out each candidate’s path to 270. Share those maps with us via Facebook or NBCPolitics.com and we might feature them online on air. Download it now for your iPad or iPhone. In this week’s Press Pass, David Gregory interviews actor Robert DeNiro from near Ground Zero. And check the blog this afternoon for The Week Ahead and The Week That Was.
*** The schedule: President Obama speaks against about student loan interest rates, this time at a high school in Arlington, VA, at 11:50 am ET. Then he hosts the 2012 NCAA Men’s Basketball champion Kentucky Wildcats at the White House at 4:50 pm ET. … Vice President Biden speaks about women’s issues at the YWCA Annual Conference in DC at 1:15 pm ET.
Countdown to Indiana Senate/Wisconsin recall primaries: 4
Countdown to Wisconsin recall election: 32
Countdown to Election Day: 186 days
Click here to sign up for First Read emails.
Text FIRST to 622639, to sign up for First Read alerts to your mobile phone.
Check us out on Facebook and also on Twitter. Follow us @chucktodd, @mmurraypolitics, @DomenicoNBC, @brookebrower


Over 12 million people out of work... But the liberals think that is a good thing.
over 3 years of over 8% unemployment, yet obama tells us all about the 2 million jobs that have been created under his run.
And all the liberals keep saying obama is adding jobs, what? more people are out of work than when he took office.
How have your GOP/Tea Party Congressional members helped? Do you really think that the Bush economic policies will save this country? Fortunately many of us can see the trees from the forest and know the truth and the facts.
Those numbers are facts!!! they come from the government agency's you liberals love to quote.
Well until the numbers go against your views. Then you make it sound like they are not the facts..
over 8% unemlpoyment for the past 3 ++ years, now show me that is not the facts.
12 million out of work, now show me that is not the facts.
Hurry now.
stupidita,
Are you deaf and mute with a broken calculator??? It was already said, November 2008 jobs were being lost at 7o,ooo per month (-70,000) during Bush.
Now, during Obama, jobs have been hiring at (+ 5o,ooo) per month after 26 straight months until job growth slowed in April to (+22,ooo) that month. Hello???? Which number is greater, Dummy???? +22,ooo or -7o,ooo ???? Have you exceeded 6th grade math???
stupidita.... your name says it all!
OBAMA/BIDEN 2012!! HILARY 2016!!!
djj,,Bush isn't a tea-partier. Bush is a liberal.
stupidita,
This argument is stupid. Do you know math??? Are you familiar with integers? Integers are positive and negative numbers along a an axis with a zero between those positive numbers and negative numbers. When Republicans were in office, our country was losing 70,000 (A NEGATIVE NUMBER WITH A MINUS) jobs per month, as they left office in 2008. Since Obama has been in office, our country has had 26 straight months of jobs hiring employees (A POSITIVE NUMBER WITH A PLUS) with a slight slowing of growth in the APRIL report (STILL A POSITIVE NUMBER). This isn't about a Liberal or Conservative argument. It's about math ......
Blog entry #156.3 proves why Coporate tax cuts Republicans promised to Grover Norquist wiould destroy America's economy. Those Idiots who do not know the past would be condemned to repeat it....like YOU. Republicans will lose in 2012 for this reason......case closed.
The premise that the jobs report helps Romney is wrong. It just gives him the same support from the same uninformed individuals who want MORE of the Bush policies that destroyed the economy. His support for the Ryan Plan proves this point. Take from the people to give to the wealthy greedy libertarians. You can fool some of the people some of the time but NOT all of the people all of the time. Just keep spinning the truth and see how far that goes. We all see how great the so-called austerity policies are working in Wisconsin and Europe.
Mitt Romney and the Republican Party are just PUPPETS!!! for the RICH!!!!!
How Stupid!!! Does Romney know the law of the land???????????
Chinese dissident Chen Guangcheng Romney would have offered him asylum. State Department spokesman Mark Toner contended, however, “You cannot achieve political asylum unless you are outside of the country you are trying to flee.”
When I heard Nordquist say that all they want/need is a conservative President with the digits on his hand to hold a pen to sign whatever the GOP wants.... I almost got physically sick! GOP gets scarier every day!
Norquist's words: Pick a Republican with enough working digits to handle a pen to become president of the United States. This is a change for Republicans: the House and Senate doing the work with the president signing bills. His job is to be captain of the team, to sign the legislation that has already been prepared.
What?????? Now this is sick! People want to vote for this?????? How scary is that?
Obama/Biden 2012!!! Hilary 2016!!!
Exlax ETCH-A-SKETCH is back on track all right! The railroad track right out of politics! His corrupt Republican corporates & their hand-picked corrupt political puppets just like him are ALL ON THEIR WAY OUT! It took them just 8 years to TOTALLY DESTROY our economy with their corrupt OIL & FINANCIAL corporates leading the way and helped bring on the GLOBAL ECONOMIC COLLAPSE because of CAPITALISTIC GREED! NOTHING MORE, NOTHING LESS!!
99% American People, vote 100% STRAIGHT DEMOCRATIC, the lives you save WILL be YOURS & your CHILDREN!!!
I understand that Willard plans to impose mormon law on America!
I'm surprised that Harry Reid hasn't done that by now.
That is one weird religion. Smith was a conman and a fraud. Go figure, just like Mittens.
I know Big business is behind this job stall just to bring down Obama in November.Them and their Republican prostitutes have been holding back since they lost the presidency four years ago.I would love to see the shape of the economy if they worked with the man and the American People instead of against them in any way they could.
Ya think? If I was rich, and I knew someone was trying to take away my ability to deduct job creation investment from my taxes, I would hold off on spending that money with the intent to use it on the extra tax. Is this a big conspiracy as you suggest, or just common sense? Unfortunately, greed is prominent in our country (not just rich people) and to fantasize that the rich will continue to invest in job creation exactly the same after they can no longer deduct it from their taxes is about as likely as getting taxes from the tooth fairy.
Hoarding money in Company Treasury sitting on huge piles of cash because like there Old scarecrow in the senate McConnell There said there aren't interested in Creating Jobs not passing any real Jobs bills there number one concern making Obama 1 term and going back to Bush Policies and outsourcing American jobs. So much so in the House No jobs bills but a bunch of kill regulations to go back to Bush policies that lost 750,000 jobs a month. Thats why the house has 11 percent Approval rating.
Do you have an issue with being realistic? There is a reason Congress created deductions for putting money into job creation investments. It's because the rich corporations didn't get rich by being generous, they got rich by investing money into something that either makes them more money or gets them a healthy tax break. Seems past Congressional bills to create these deductions were realistic and knew this, but evidently you don't. Obama wants to eliminate the benefit of the job creation deductions, and to not expect this would affect the money invested in job creation is possibly the dumbest thing this administration has come up with. On the other hand, if you raised the base rate (which is 35% now) to something around 50%, and allowed them to continue to utilized deductions to lower their effective rate to around 30% (Obama's goal), then they would continue to invest in beneficial deductions such as charities, job creation, etc. Coming up with a plan and not even putting 10 seconds to think about how it would affect investments is stupid politics.
You just gotta ask the question: If millionaire will not be able to lower their tax rates by putting money into things they can deduct, how likely do you think they will continue to put the money there rather than use that money instead to pay the extra tax. True, there are so many deductions, and probably many of them are being abused, but evidently the same Congress that created these deductions and loop-holes did so because the were proven methods to:
Create jobs, reduce polution, promote green energy, help charities, reduce the need for imports, reduce jobs going to foreign countries, etc, etc
Think maybe a few of the rich have been holding back on these investment deductions with the intent to use the money for the possible extra tax instead?
DOH, don't figure, does it.
Obama 2012...."Aint nobody got time for dat" Says Sweet Mrs Brown
Its win win for the Democrats. If Romney wins it will be the same as if Obama never left. 2 guys in the same suit if you will. Isn't politics great?
Block Clooney's fundraising for Obama.
Demonstrate and protest against it.
He's trying to raise 12 million.
Block The Supreme Court Of Injustice and Republicans from Buying Elections with overseas China money for the Thousands of American Jobs the Republicans are pledging to send them in Foreign lands Republicans love to do like Romney Destroy the country/Company from within give the CEOs and Owners huge Raises and Tax cuts Fire all workers and ship the job overseas to send the product they create there back here to sell to our Country because they want us to be just that stupid to buy it. WE cant let Republicans and Tea baggers destroy Medicare, SS, Medicasid and give huge tax cuts even bigger then the Bush tax cuts to the extremely rich and Cut all programs that help the poor and middle class.
Obama and Democrats in 2012.......
My job was outsourced in 2005 to India. I had to accept a lower paying job to get by. Real estate started losing value before Bush left office, when the Bank crisis hit. Eight years of Bush left our economy in tatters. The last best year was 1999, and which party was in office? The Dem's and they should have been in 2000, if Florida hadn't faked their results. Do you really expect Obama to fix all this in 4 years?
Mormons are crazy. Wake up the religious right. Why are you voting for an egocentric non-christian? What would Jesus say?
No I do not expect Obama to fix everything in the next 4 years but do you really think Gordon Gecko Romney will help matters?! He never created jobs, he destroyed them. His private equity firm, Bain Capital acquired companies, sucked out the equity and closed them down. Hey--we have had 30 years of Reaganomics (supply side, trickle down) so you cannot expect instant gratification. Obama has many faults but the alternative is so much worse!
As for your job being sent to India, I would tax to death any company that engaged in such conduct. But with the Republicans in Congress you will never see such legislation. Do you think voting for Republicans will fix the problem?! No way--their creed is greed, their god is Mamon and their master, Satan. Vote for someone who at least leaves something for the working man!
What really surprises me is that none of the press are standing up to the peanut brained pointy headed right wing extremists who are trying to seize power. When Joe McCarthy created a threat there was Edward R. Murrow to stand up to him. When the Vietnam debacle showed its true colors there was Walter Cronkite. But now--there is nobody. The press gives Romney lots of free time and we see talking heads either telling us what he is up to or praising his wife. Nothing is said about the agenda he now endorses. Romney has signed on to the right wing extremist agenda and the press should be denouncing him. If he is elected he will rubber stamp the tea party agenda and together they will drive the bus right over the cliff. Now--there might be an initial boom since big business will rightfully think it can do anything it wants so you might see an initial hiring boom. However, a few years down the road, you will see more Lehman Brothers type problems and a depression which will make 1931 look like a Christmas Party!
Romney is the "I love to Fire Americans" Candidate and Hire China they got 4 percent and Firing 500,000 Americans like Bush did 750,000 and month is the direction Romney would like to go "Greece 2.0 and Ryan Budget"
Just like the cherry picking that drivels from Reich Wing keyboards in any discussion of climate, the GOP/Teatards are all too gleefully ready to pounce on any thin thread that detracts from the steady recovery we have seen from the Bush/Cheney disaster.
How can any rational discussion of economic data pretend to hide from the simple fact that this is an intrinsically noisy data set? You can bet that none of these well heeled Grover lovers would base their investment decisions on the most recent twitch in a stock price!
Follow the Romney/Ryan Teatards only if you are a fan of austerity driven Great Depressions, and then BOHICA!
I must use my personal experience when deciding who is best to lead the country.
During the 8 long Bush years, I was unemployed a total of 2.5 years.
During the Obama years, I have been fully employed so far.
I have also done better in the stock market during the Obama years than the Bush years.
Obama 2012!
Congrats, Wireman...for being unique. I have experienced and heard the direct opposite everywhere around me in MA... not to forget all the unemployed college grads, while he's interfering in stopping illegal immigration....which indirectly affects ALL employment. Former Presidents have slowed down on ANY immigration in such times.
Never in my not-so-short lifetime have I seen this country so badly off. It WAS the economy, silly, (on day one of this administration) to be FIXED...not to waste time on a fraudulent Health Care farce, and OTHER "exercises" in Socialism. In about 31/2 short years, we're going down more rapidly than ever in history on HIS watch!!
The only game he's played well is "The Blame Game"!!!
Annie, I would explain the health-care situation to you but it is clear you can't handle the truth. You can try to rewrite history, but you can't change the fact that things are finally starting to get better after the 8 long year Bush disaster.
Annie, It takes more than 4 years to UnBushwack an economy! Obama can't change the laws of physics.
OBAMA 2012!
Obama killed Bin Laden. Don’t let the right wingers changed the subject. Obama killed Bin Laden. If they point to the jobs report, tell them Obama killed Bin Laden. If they tell you Obama added more to the debt in three years than Bush did in eight, tell them Obama killed Bin Laden. If they say the unemployment rate is 8.2%, tell them Obama killed Bin Laden. If they tell you the GNP increased only 2% in the first quarter, tell them Obama killed Bin Laden. If you are a new college grad and can’t find a job, just remember Obama killed Bin Laden. If they asked you why the nation is so divided after Obama had promised to bring people of all races, creed, religion and gender together, remind them Obama killed Bin Laden. If Romney ask are you better off today than you were four years ago, tell him hell yeah, Obama killed Bin Laden. Don't let the right wingers forget Obama killed Bin Laden.
We could talk about how 3+ decades of Conservative trickle down Economics and deregulation as a religion brought us the worst economic crash since the Great Depression.
Happy now?