House Republican leaders said Monday that they will ready legislation to extend the payroll tax cut without offsetting its cost through the end of 2012 as a backstop in case lawmakers' efforts to authorize a comprehensive extension of that and unemployment benefits fail.
House Speaker John Boehner (OH), Majority Leader Eric Cantor (VA) and Majority Whip Kevin McCarthy (CA) announced the alternative route amid signs that the formal conference committee in charge of crafting a compromise bill on the expiring unemployment insurance and tax cuts has stalled.
"Because the president and Senate Democratic leaders have not allowed their conferees to support a responsible bipartisan agreement, today House Republicans will introduce a backup plan that would simply extend the payroll tax holiday for the remainder of the year while the conference negotiations continue regarding offsets, unemployment insurance, and the ‘doc fix,'" the trio said in a statement. "If Democrats continue to refuse to negotiate in good faith, Republicans may schedule this measure for House consideration later this week pending a conversation with our members."
Congress extended the expiring benefits at the end of December, shortly before each had been scheduled to lapse after Dec. 31. That agreement wasn't reached, however, until House Republicans relented on their demand that the programs be extended for all of calendar year 2012, along with having their costs fully offset.
Republicans agreed to the short-term extension only in exchange for the formal "conference" process intended to resolve differences between House and Senate legislation. But that reversal only came after a number of Republicans accused their House colleagues of politically damaging intransigence.
But with just a few weeks left to go until the Feb. 28 deadline, the conference committee appears mired in stalemate, with disagreement falling along familiar fault lines. Democrats wish to impose new revenue-raising measures on the wealthiest Americans to finance the tax cuts and benefit extensions, while Republicans decry such efforts as tax hikes, and wish to find savings instead through budget cuts.
The GOP's maneuver on Monday is a bid to put Democrats on their heels, and push back against the narrative that President Obama has used to great effect, casting Republicans as having obstructed middle-class tax relief by playing politics. If Congress were to authorize the tax cut extension without offsets -- something for which Democrats have pushed -- Republicans would conceivably be able to deny responsibility for the failure of negotiations.
Pelosi herself has told reporters repeatedly that she does not believe the payroll tax cut should be paid for as it is an "emergency" program implemented during a down economy. Boehner admits in his statement that "this is not our first choice," which reflects the fact that many in the Republican conference, especially conservative members, believe that this tax cut, if it's done at all, should have its cost offset. The total cost of the 10-month extension is around $100 billion.
Because of that conservative opposition, the bill would likely need to rely on Democratic support to pass, putting Democrats in the tough position of being forced to vote for a tax cut they have been pushing Republicans to pass.


It seems to be the case that having the Tea Party folk in Congress is only going to clog the system. It may be better to let Obama run wild with rubber stamp legislation, letting the more moderate Dems control how wild it gets. Then at least something gets done and we can see what works and what needs to be fixed. The way it is, nothing ever gets done and so we don't know what we can actually get away with and what we cannot.
This is a sad state! But history shows the same stuff during Adams and Jefferson reign. They had their own News Papers writing about each other in a negative way! Many Hated Hamilton and his Banking ideas!
Many still do.
Same ol same ol from these repubs. They want their cake, frosting, and ice cream too. And then, they expect to eat it also. All at the expense of our getting this economy going again. Why must they always play these games??? I'm talking about both sides, why play these games??? Get over yourselves, and help!!!!
It's an election year. Republicans can run, but they cannot save their hides if they keep attacking middle class interests. They are playing under the lights and Main Street is watching, not just Wall Street and lobbyists.
Please stop this nonsense about drug testing folks who recieve "Government Benefits". Social Secutity is a government benefit, so is the GI Bill, and let's not overlook those of us who are Honorably Discharged Disabled Veterans who recieve Service Connected government benefits.
If that does not end the debate then please look at what happend in Florida when they drug tested welfare recipients. Since only 2% of the folks on welfare tested positive for drugs, the test cost 5 times more than the money that was saved from denying government benefits to those who tested positive. In other words, not a dime was saved and in fact the cost of the programs were increased by the millions of dollars wasted on testing everyone.
I suspect the same might be true if you want to drug test everyone who recieves "government benefits" including Social Security, GI Bill and VA government benefit recipients.
The government wastes enough money on foolish things...please stop pushing this one...
What I was waiting for was for Rick Scott to say that drug users' kids had to go hungry since their mommy's pee was tainted. It sure made for a long line at Quest and LabCorp, though.
as long as the tax cut gets extended then good. but they can end it if they want to end all the loopholes for the top.
I'm really tired of Republican posturing. They blame the Democrats for the economy, and the deficit. Yet they fight virtually everything the Democrats propose, no matter what economists say. If they had any real ideas, they lost them many years ago.
agree
Which economists are you referring to? You must be talking about some Ivy league economists. They seem to be the only ones who come up with the magical numbers that Obama loves to use (e.g. "saved or created 4 million jobs"). They seem to be the only ones who think that more borrowing and spending seems to be the answer for an overspending problem. It must be because they are so much smarter than everyone else and that our non-Ivy league little peanut brains just can't comprehend something so complex like Magical Economics.
Don't you wish there were real candidates that the Republicans could bring forward. All the numbers suggest Obama just kicks their ass in the election and that is not what the country needs now. A real debate to make them both accountable is needed
Yep. The republican party is broken and messed up.
Fix it and clean up the mess.
"GOP readies payroll tax backstop"
Feh! More empty words and posing from "The Gang That Couldn't
ShootThink Straight."agree
There they go again. Mr grover, the gop, & the rushbo socking it to the little guy. The people on social security. The poor. The handicapped. While protecting the income of the upper 1% as though their jobs depended upon it. They want our country to be another greece.
It will be based on the Obama spending levels. Dam why must this continue. The Republicans can't Stop it!
Yes, everybody wants to be -- is trying to be -- just like Greece, because rioting in the street benefits everyone, especially the top 1% whose property is, of course, disproportionately being destroyed, so much!
These elitists who run the whole show sure have driven a wedge between the red and the blue public. If we don't come together we are screwed, period!!!!How in the hell are we going to get around this divisivness? It goes way beyond the right and the left.
I suggest you all educate yourselves, for beginners ......google this
The world bank and the IMF: banking on misery.
Then google IMF/world bank destroying countries
What we need to concentrate on is giving a crammed course of what is really going on in the large picture. The general public in all nations need to know the facts and get educated quick and in a hurry. Things are happening really fast and we need to be prepared. A lot of people all over the world see whats happening....beyond their propaganda machine. We here are so propagandized. We need to pull our heads our of our right and left arses and get busy taking this country back.
Fact is the U.S. Germany, Japan, Britain and France are the majority stakeholders in the IMF and world bank. The world bank is a demon child and if you google the second article I asked you to you will learn how the world bank works and what it does. Basically turns everyone into slaves.
So go get educated, look for news in other countries (they all have news in English as well) see what they are saying that you don't hear over here. Get info everywhere you can don't just listen to our news and info we get.
Good luck and get serious and lets stop all this left right bs.
Our country and our rights have been taken away from us over many years. This did'nt just happen overnight. Once they get rid of cash and have us all on the plastic and using only didgits on a damned computor we will all be beholden to the bankers and their masters. They can freeze our accts at a whim and they can even steal our money and get away with it.
Stop!! Great now I'm going to have to sleep with the lights on. Thanx. But your are totaly correct. The problem is the bigger the lie the government tells the more apt people will believe them.
The World Bank (technically, the International Bank for Development) and the IMF lend money to poor countries and then tell them how to spend it. Many of these poor countries have very undemocratic regimes and the money largely goes to family members and/or cronies of the rulers rather than to the purposes for which it is supposedly dedicated. But the taxpayers of these countries (and frequently, the taxpayers of the subsidizing/guaranteeing Western countries) get stuck with the bill. Often the things which actually wind up getting built with these borrowed funds serve only the needs of the elite few in the countries where they are built (and, of course, the contractors building them). Another reason why so much of what is done in the name of "foreign aid" and "compassion" is really deleterious to those whom it supposedly helps.
The people who put these republicans in office should hide their face's in the toilet because any person in the U.S can say no with no reason for saying it, talk about a bunch of flip flopping retards who have listen to the biggest illiterate fool on the planet in Glover Norquist. These republican clearly have let their undercover racism in which they would be in denial on purpose until they go to their graves get totally in the way of common sense and pure logic.
The GOP is pissed off that they have only clowns running this time, and none of their clowns can win.
So what to do??
Obstruct, Spin and Deflect!
Don't worry the inept clown mascarading as a pres will have his flip-flopping behind evicted from the whitehouse this year. obama's lies and flip-flops are two transparent. Hopefully obama and his thugs wont steal everything not nailed down when they get tossed out.
You really are thick as a plank aren't you 7.62? There you go again, without a clue, being danced around the bonfire by the Republican Party, who convinces you to vote against your own self interests while you are making a public spectacle of yourself dancing away in ever diminishing circles with a big grin on your face and both thumbs is the perfect position to be broken by one well placed kick to your butt and not a single idea of how the middle class is being taken apart, divided and drained by the GOP and their handlers, the 1%.
LOL keep on believing your god obama you deserve him.
I tell you obama is not a flip flopper. He is asking mr grover, the gop, & the rushbo the same things as before. It is because what was right then is still right today. As in greece, the rich in this country pay too little in taxes. Yet they want war with iran, oil from the middle east.
marshall-2837579: Because the gop wants thing's that are free for them and their buddies which is the biggest hand out you can get, the lobbist and big corporations have them over a barrel which is worse than welfare, they have gave their souls away to the highest bidder.
This is hilarious! The Republicans caved and will add the cost of the payroll tax cut to the deficit rather than have income over one million/ year taxed. Now they will criticise the Obama budget for deficits. They look more inept every day!
This is hilarious. People want to cut what they pay into social security and then they are going to be the first ones crying and rioting in the streets when they don't get a check when they retire. Then they will blame rich people for not paying all of their retirement for them. They look even more inept every day!
I'm going to retire horizontally. Good thing I have a secure job I like.
Yeah sure John and Eric, just blame it on the Democrats and kick that can down the road a bit further! No wonder nothing gets done...
It is both parties playing politics unfortunately Democrats are blaming Republicans and Republicans are blaming Democrats.
Bottom line: BOTH parties are to blame!
Just settle for 10% across the board cuts. The military alone would give us a half trillion dollars.
I guess if you are a Republican you can do nothing correctly. So, why don't we just have a dictatorship like President Obama wants?
You Libs are so pathetic you were complaining in December that Republicans were not going to sign the Bill and now that they are extending the tax cut you are complaining.
Good grief DemoRATS what do you want?
Answer: Government to tell everyone who they can and can't marry, what they can put in their own bodies, more incentives for people not to work, using the power of law to force others to pay their way in life, a new constitution that allows the president to be a dictator, etc.
Anything to get some fence sitter's on the GOP side. They don't have much else to offer, and the party still hasn't chosen a leader in front of all else.
This NO "leader of the pack" so close to election time tells me that it is coming down to throwing @!$%# against a wall just to see what sticks.
Ask Limbaugh and Hannity. 2 of the best media @!$%# thrower's in this election cycle.
The gov should lay off 1/2 the emp's., and cut the budget by 1/2, then, cut our tax rate by 1/2. There should be NO tax increase as if the gov ballances the budget in a REALISTIC fashion they would have the money they need.Try putting a life time cap on food stamps and welfare at 1 year max per person as that would force the lazy bottom feeders to get a job even if they got to relocate to work the fields.
But then who would vote progressives into office if they could no longer use the power of law to steal from the productive/wealthier people of society and redistribute the money to others to create dependents who vote for them?
All for slavery are we? Let's cut the limb that we're standing on and see what happens. Few jobs equals less demand, less demand means more lay offs more lay offs means more poor more poor equals more bottom feeders. Musical chairs anyone? Oh lets just go with trickle down it has worked so well for 30 plus yrs.
So you don't believe in trickle down economics but you believe in a large federal government that taxes the wealthy and hope that the money will eventually trickle down to the people who need help in your community. Wouldn't it make more sense to take care of these matters at the local level where there is more oversight and you can actually see where the money goes? Just sayin.
BTW, subsidizing unemployment only breeds more unemployment. Ever notice how like 1/3 of people who run out of unemployment benefits miraculously find a job within about a month. Must just be a coincidence that the economy magically grows by a third every time people run out of benefits.
Well jon there's a lot of field work that needs done. If I had no problems working in the fields no one else should. Personaly I started working in the fields when I was 8, and if I never picked enough flats at the end of the day I got my butt beat, if I got fired for throwing berries I got my butt beat, and had to work on a wood pile from 5am untill 6pm when my dad got home. That's how I got to spend my summers growing up. Making a life time cap on foodstamps and welfare at 1 year max per person will give people the motivation to do the undesirable work if needed.
Give the poor and middleclass more tax cuts and watch the 1% figure some way to get that money. That's what they are good at.
A drug test? I better get to studying... :)
Wonder how many folks realize the payroll tax cut has to do with social security? It is very irresponsible for these lawmakers to be doing what they are doing.
Steve,
Evidence to back up your claim?
Other than this from FOX?
http://www.foxnews.com/politics/2012/02/13/republicans-look-to-unpaid-extension-payroll-tax-fault-democrats-for-refusing/
Steve???
Yeah we should have let Bush privatize it when he wanted to, remember him leaning on the filing cabinate saying its a bunch of useless bonds the money would be better used in the free market. Oh but then there was the crash never mind.
Jonathan,
Maybe you should simply google the words "Galveston and Social Security" and see how retirement programs can be run better at a local level with more individual options and oversight. 3 counties in Texas opted out of social security (when you actually could) in the early 1980s and their retirement programs are thriving. Better managed with better oversight. Putting individuals in charge of their own retirement is a better option than entrusting your retirement to a money/power hungry government. Nice try though, thanks for playing. We have some lovely parting gifts for you.
How can the president say that his budget will improve our economy? If he is not re-elected, there will be another budget to change his budgets. If he is re-elected, his own future budgets will destroy this proposal!
He is living in his own little fantasy world, hoping that his daughters will make enough money to bail out his crazy proposals!!!
Better his then mine. Oh that will never happen.
Willjohn,
After reading your post, I envision a dog chasing his tail.
Try again, and this time try to make some sense.
They are willing to pass a bill that is not paid for because they refuse to raise taxes on their wealthy supporters. This just proves that they have no interest in cutting the deficit, they are only interested in protecting their wealthy supporters.
Pathological hypocrites, is the appropriate term, I believe.
The train is leaving the station and the GOP faithful have to choose between a right wing fanatic and an honest to God elitist, neither of which is electable so the rats in the Congress are scurrying to protect their seats in the House and Senate with this wishy washy, flip flopping, mamby pamby proposal that shouldn't be necessary to begin with. The once Mighty Republican House of Cards is starting to sway in the breeze of middle class discontent and is not much longer in this political world. Regan would be even more confused and addle than he seemed most of the time if he were alive to see where and with whom his party has chosen to bed down.
We need a revolution in this country as soon as possible .
Entitlements from Senior and the disabled being taken away secretly because the press will not print stories about this including Cnbc . If you Google medicare suits you will find out that the disable chronic pt are being denied payment for their medical treatment because the Obama has a machine to lie to the public. So the Hell with Democrat and DD to the Republicans as this is what these policies and practices have done to me .
Next . YOU ALL ARE BEING TREATED AS COMPLETE FOOLS . Obama is buying your vote by allowing WHAT HE SPINS AS A PAYROLL REDUCTION . IN FACT THIS IS YOUR INSURANCE PREMIUM CALLED FICA THAT PAYS FOR YOUR SOCIAL SECURITY AND MEDICARE IF YOU REACH RETIREMENT AGE . TO Wit , if you are the type of person that says , that you hope you die before the age of Retirement and means this - and you have a death wish -= which this indicates then - this doesn't apply === but if you want a retirement with benefits that you paid for then you should be insulted and vote All Democrats out . = but this is worse than you can even imagine and the reason why Republicans are for you getting no or little benefits that you paid for is because they want all the top doctors and hospitals to beckon to them . Why is this . Well , the Republicans want you NOT TO KNOW THAT YOU CAN NOT BUY HEALTH INSURANCE NOW AS YOUR PRIMARY TO BE GIVEN TO YOU ONCE YOU REACH THE AGE OF 65 BECAUSE DESPITE WHATEVER INSURANCE YOU HAD BEFORE YOU REACH THE GOVT AGE OF RETIREMENT , YOU WILL LOSE IT AS YOUR PRIMARY INSURANCE BECAUSE THE GOVERNMENT MADE A LAW THAT THE ONLY PRIMARY INSURANCE YOU CAN HAVE TO RECEIVE SOCIAL SECURITY INCOME AND MEDICARE IS MEDICARE . YOU CAN NOT BUY A PRIMARY TO REPLACE MEDICARE .
What is the choice you have now as the Government is corrupt not allowing chronic conditions to be paid for as chronic conditions to doctors ? Well when the doctors are not paid for services in the current case for any chronic conditions treatments in the manor they (Secy of Health or Obama) determine in whole or part , the Doctor QUIT MEDICARE OR MEDICAID FOR THIS chronic treatment . E.g., for arthritic knees the Medicare will not approve of Knee replacement operation for people over a certain age , and then they too will not approve of any modalities such as ulrtasoud other than drugs including pain killers for this arthritis . Get it if it costs money for a chronic condition then they will not approve it . It get a lot worse than this . E.g. there is now a limit on modalities one will receive if they have a terminal condition , so that if you want some medical necessity over a certain price Medicare or Obama and his Secy says we will not cover it . Die and get it over with so the US can save money on your suffering . The point is you are forced into this situation unless you are rich you will die in suffering because you will be bankrupted by Hitler Obama , and your suffering is not going to picked up by your family either . Most likely they don;t even discuss the problem being created or care . The excuse from one person to the other or spin is we didn't;t know . The same excuse in Nazi Germany when when Jews were being baked to death in ovens .
To buy votes Obama Hitler who is worse this way has approved the approval of homosexual acts . By allowing sexual anal sex in marriage they have approve the same of homosexual acts in dating . More importantly , Obama is worse than Hitler in at least Hitler did not approve of Homosexual marriages . Understand , that you have now have to have judges who have to determine what is normal marriage act expected in homosexual and bisexual marriages and the deprive of this act in heterosexual marriages is a reason for divorce . This places marriage in danger in heterosexual marriages . It reminds me of the Madona film where Madonna plays a woman who supposedly used her sexuality to keep her man , and she then used the fact she had a large settlement from a rich man because unknown to the court , she found that the man cheated on her , not with another woman , but with another man. This is why this become very complicated .
Now Obama intends to stick drones up our Azzzes . That is right while he is buying votes by this buying of vote by allowing Biblical perversions he is at the same time , going to be spying of everyone . Get it , by drones . The essential point is our privacy is sacrificed by drones . Get this the US has money to spy on Americans by no money to treat chronic pts . I am listening the the BS er Riley on Fox . This Sob is complaining about the use of drugs in the US and even blames the death of Ms Whitney of prescribed drugs well this span artist deserves to be called this as what is stated in the Medicare legal cases which show the Sec'y of Health or Obama lackey , stopping Chronic medical care pt billing from not being paid and the treatment of choice is as Riley indicates or drugs instead of modalities that would avoid drugs and which modalities Medicare will not pay for .
The Rich can afford designer drugs and recreation drugs . More important they can pay for doctors who will not accept Medicare or deny treatment Medicare will not pay for . Hitler Parties who include both parties , call the denial of treatment capitalism . This is called theft . Medicare is forced on the retiree . Medicare was paid for complete medical care in ones elder years through fica . The two Hitler parties are thieves and killers of the elderly and the disabled .
Here is McCain telling how they are going to ship 800 million dollars to Egypt . This is a county ruled by the military . The point is simple , for some reason the US politicians are always giving money away in wars to get back this money . The accounting for the money goes in someone pocket . This money in the pork chain , where someone give back part they receive as there is no accounting for the chain of this money. This was true in Iraq and Iraq was for this porking .
We have a 145 trillion dollar deficit and the reason you don;t know about this is because it became this way through porking . They will tell you entitlements are owed . Well Social security was stolen . Fica payments were stolen and a IOU given in its place by Congress . This was called Paygo and is still so called . You take billions and this goes into whose bank account and makes interest or some one investments thought this pork of supposedly giving money to Egypt and you get no accounting to those who actually get it and it use . It is a gift and a gift back . This is called pork . It come from the Social Security Fund as this is not funded and the over-funding under Paygo , slush fund ,uses this for Gifts and gift back called pork or theft . This is Sop for the Congress . You want to give money to Israel . Well , I am sure Israel will account for a stream of at least 80% of the money to show where it went . Try this with other countries and MCCaintrip is of the potential bag man under these so called charity concepts .
Look if the USA want to give 800 million to Egypt , let them build power plant partially owned by the US in Egypt with US employees similar to the the Chinese give money to other countries , but then the US porkers will not be in favor of this because of their payoff . The Chinese get paid off by allowing protection for other companies owned by the Govt coming into their nation e.g. oil companies.
You remind me of the guy in "Conspiracy Theory" who was 99.99999% wrong about everything that he preached but hit one fact on the head. I will leave it to you and the other readers to identify the truth that you hit upon while flailing at the keyboard.
But I'd have to plow through all of that! It can't be that great of a fact!
Liberals are complaining over what Obama wanted...The payroll tax cuts extended...It was ridiculous to extend them for 2 months in the first place
What's really got their butts in a wad, is the GOP out smarted Obama...He gets part of what he wanted and it beneifits the middle class, the holiday tax cuts extended, but...the big BUT...only without offsets...
Lets see who obstructs the middle-class tax relief by playing politics now...
The GOP has obviously outsmarted you but then again how hard could that be when they already have you voting against your own self interests.