First Thoughts: Didn't we almost have it all?

Robert F. Bukaty / AP

Republican presidential candidate Mitt Romney speaks at a caucus, Saturday, Feb. 11, 2012, in Portland, Maine.

Romney survives over the weekend by winning Maine caucuses and CPAC straw poll… His struggle so far: an “excitement deficit”… Breaking down the 18 different contests over a 15-day period… Paul campaign disputes Romney’s Maine victory… How to judge the White House’s birth-control compromise: If we’re still talking about it this week (and so far today, it isn’t a topic of conversation)… And Obama to discuss his budget at 11:00 am ET in Northern Virginia. 


*** Didn’t we almost have it all? Perhaps the best way to view Mitt Romney’s weekend is that he survived. He couldn’t afford to lose the Maine caucuses (and have the storyline exist that he lost four-straight contests). He couldn’t fare poorly in the CPAC straw poll (especially after his “severely conservative” line). And guess what: He won both. They weren’t impressive victories, and they both had their controversies -- a Maine county postponed its caucus, while Rick Santorum accused the Romney camp of rigging the straw poll (but isn’t that exactly what a straw poll is?) But both events showed that they can win, even when it isn’t pretty. And that very well might be the theme of Romney’s entire primary fight: winning ugly. Still, a win is a win…

*** So (not) emotional: On Sunday, the New York Times’ Frank Bruni did a good job of summing up why Romney is struggling, even when he wins: His candidacy has an “excitement deficit.” Bruni writes, “It’s hard to find a single Republican, including those most solidly behind him, who demonstrates true passion for him or can do even a persuasive pantomime of it. They call him effective, not inspirational. They praise his competence, not his charisma. He doesn’t exert any sort of gravitational pull on his party. There’s no full swoon.” He concludes, “Almost all of the presidents elected over recent decades have been propelled by pockets of intense enthusiasm, which can paper over so many specific political predicaments and eclipse tensions with the base. They were saviors before they were disappointments, not disappointments right out of the gate. And almost all of them had something solid — a resonant personal story or an outsize personality or a bold vision — for admirers to latch onto. Romney wafts through a voter’s fingers, a puff of presidential-looking air.”

*** All at once: Looking ahead in the GOP primary race, there will be 18 different contests over a 15-day period. And here’s a good way to score their outcome: If Romney isn’t the guy with the most combined delegates, then we may very well be headed for a brokered convention. Here are 18 contests in 15 days:

Tuesday, Feb. 28: Michigan (primary), Arizona (primary)
Saturday, Mar. 3
: Washington (caucus)
Tuesday, Mar. 6
: (Super Tuesday): Alaska (caucus), Georgia (primary), Idaho (caucus), Massachusetts (primary), North Dakota (caucus), Ohio (primary), Oklahoma (primary), Tennessee (primary), Vermont (primary), Virginia (primary), Wyoming (caucus)
Saturday, Mar. 10
: Kansas (caucus)
Tuesday, Mar. 13
: Alabama (primary), Hawaii (caucus), Mississippi (primary)

GOP candidate Rick Santorum says he is focusing on a "two-person race" with Mitt Romney as Sarah Palin is speaking out to question Romney's conservative credentials.  NBC's Peter Alexander reports.

*** I want to dance with somebody: Given all of these different contests, here’s an early look where the individual campaigns plan to spend their time. Romney: Arizona on Monday; Michigan on Wednesday and Thursday; Idaho on Friday; and Utah on Saturday. Santorum: Washington state on Monday (same day same-sex marriage gets signed into law in that state); Idaho on Tuesday; and Michigan on Thursday. Gingrich: California (which doesn’t hold its contest until June 5) from Monday through Thursday; and Georgia on Friday. Indeed, don’t lose sight on Gingrich’s disappearing schedule. Gingrich seems to be in a SERIOUS cash crunch given he’s spending his ENTIRE week, basically, fundraising. 

*** How will I know (if Romney really won Maine)? What is it with the Republican Party and its caucuses? First was the controversy over the Iowa results -- with the state party saying that Romney came out on top only to later reverse course and declare Santorum the winner. Next was Nevada, which held its caucuses at different times and with one special caucus site forcing participants to sign a legal declaration under the penalty of perjury that they couldn’t attend earlier caucuses because of their religious beliefs. And then on Saturday, one Maine county (Washington County) postponed its caucus -- due to snow -- until Feb. 18, which allowed the Paul campaign to cry foul and make the case it could have won if there hadn’t been a postponement. By the way, Ron Paul still hasn’t won a single contest so far...

*** My love is your love: In Maine (without the results from Washington County), turnout was up slightly (2.6%) from 2008 -- 5,585 people voted this year in the weeklong caucuses, up from 5,446 in 2008. But even though Romney won, that turnout increase appeared driven by Paul supporters. Romney got 23% fewer votes (2,190 votes versus 2,826), and Paul doubled his 2008 showing (1,996 votes, up 100% from 999 in 2008). There's also been a big difference between Romney's turnout in the first four contests and the last four. Overall, the frontrunner's seen a 14% increase in the number of people voting for him this year than in 2008. But in the first four highly contested contests, where Romney and his Super PAC spent millions of dollars in advertising promoting himself and attacking others, Romney's turnout was up 38%. But in the last four, his turnout is down 60%.

*** On the trail: Gingrich holds a Hispanic leadership event in California… Romney is in Arizona, where he attends a get-out-the-vote rally in Mesa… And Santorum holds a rally in Tacoma, WA.

*** It’s not right, but it’s OK: Maybe the best way to judge if the White House’s compromise/accommodation on birth control was a success is if the issue is still a topic of conversation this week. And so far, it isn’t. (However, 42 conservative leaders say they’re opening a “united front to battle Obama” on this issue.) Indeed, it’s doubtful the issue will have any impact on November’s presidential contest. But don’t be surprised if it plays a role in some of the Senate contests, especially in the Midwest (Missouri, Ohio, Wisconsin.). Tough for the cultural wedge issues to stay top of mind in a presidential. But down the ballot? Different story.

*** Same script, different cast: All presidential budgets are political documents, and the one President Obama will unveil today -- in a presidential year -- is no different. The New York Times: “In his budget Mr. Obama again will commit to $4 trillion in deficit reduction over 10 years, including $1.5 trillion in tax revenue from the wealthy and from closing some corporate tax breaks, and reductions in spending for a range of programs, including the military, Medicare, farm subsidies and federal pensions. But Republicans are sure to criticize the president’s proposals as heavy on gimmickry and double-counting, and reject his proposed tax increases. For all the debate over deficits, Mr. Obama on Monday will highlight spending increases and tax cuts that he seeks, which are popular despite their impact on the federal debt.” He will discuss his budget at 11:00 am ET at Northern Virginia Community College in Annandale, VA. Bottom line on this budget: Thanks to some spending caps and other agreements from previous showdowns, this is a document designed for the presidential campaign -- Obama is emphasizing his spending priorities (coupled with some familiar tax policy) hoping to have THAT conversation with swing voters. So where does he start? In a swing state at a community college. This is a page, frankly, ripped from the Clinton playbook of the ‘90s.

Countdown to Super Tuesday: 22 days
Countdown to Election Day: 267 days

Click here to sign up for First Read emails.
Text FIRST to 622639, to sign up for First Read alerts to your mobile phone.
Check us out on Facebook and also on Twitter. Follow us @chucktodd, @mmurraypolitics, @DomenicoNBC, @brookebrower

Discuss this post

Jump to discussion page: 1 2 3

But i think that ben & jerry has a better idea than mr grover, the gop, & the rushbo who believe that money & only money should determine who runs the country. Support ben & jerry's program of getting the dough out of politics. It's a great idea & completely in line with occupy.

  • 1 vote
Reply#52 - Tue Feb 14, 2012 12:59 AM EST

This one has SHARE written all over it!!! The Ron Paul campaign came forward Saturday claiming the establishment is purposely hiding Maine’s overall caucus results and delegate totals from the American people to prevent any potential surge or momentum from taking place as a result of the success he had in the caucus. Continue reading on Examiner com http://www.examiner.com/conspiracy-in-denver/ron-paul-campaign-establishment-hiding-maine-caucus-results

    Reply#53 - Tue Feb 14, 2012 1:10 AM EST

    News of Whitney Houston’s death came as a shock to fans around the world. Unbid tears have flowed. The circumstances are neither pretty nor proper, but the repeated message from the Beverly Hills police and coroner was that there was no evidence of foul play.

    In response to the overwhelming coverage of Whitney’s passing on social and mainstream media, some question Whitney Houston’s relevance – especially considering that her history of substance abuse and reckless lifestyle does not make her an ideal role-model.

    URL:

      Reply#54 - Tue Feb 14, 2012 2:33 AM EST

      The catholic church must first follow its own rules.. what is their stance on molestation. Specifically priest that molest their parishioners.

      Anyone on here defending the Catholic church speak up. The same church that wants to cry religious persecution while operating as a for profit enterprise all while benefiting from exempt tax status.

      Really trying to have it's choir boy and molest him too (you know like have your cake and eat it too)

      • 1 vote
      Reply#55 - Tue Feb 14, 2012 9:52 AM EST

      No matter how many times and how he repackages himself, the product is still the same old crap.

      Amazing how in 30 short years the Republican party have reduced to rhetoric and Soviet style propaganda. Completely bankrupt of ideas, they rely on big business executives to guide them through campaigns, public interviews and policy.

      The US has been reduced to one legitimate party, Democrats, and that is also very dangerous. The Republicans need a good thorough purge of the bad apples and shed the three piece suit lobbyist or the US is head for third world status.

      GOP, the Party of the rich, by the rich, for the rich, shall screw the poor.

      "No no no no. No no. You've got to take the whole sentence, all right, as opposed to saying, and then change it just a little bit, because then it sounds very different. I've said throughout the campaign my focus, my concern, my energy is gonna be devoted to helping middle income people, all right? We have a safety net for the poor in, and if there are holes in it, I will work to repair that. And if there are people that are falling through the cracks I want to fix that," Romney said. "Wealthy people are doing fine. But my focus in the campaign is on middle income people. Of course I'm concerned about all Americans -- poor, wealthy, middle class, but the focus of my effort will be on middle income families who I think have been most hurt by the Obama economy."

      So incredibly stupid ... even after some thought and brainstorm with the other morons in his campaign he not only repeats the mistake, putting a conditional scenario before taking any action to help people, ... he adds more stupidity by proposing a discriminatory policy to cover his perception of an American class structured society.

      This idiot has absolutely no clue what the Office of the Presidency is about, let alone what leadership is about.

      Sorry Mr Romney but you are not qualified to fill the position of President, go away.

        Reply#56 - Tue Feb 14, 2012 4:22 PM EST

        Bill O'reilly is the biggest republican PUKE on the planet for what he said about Whitney Houston!!! I hope that everyone of her FANS vote against all the republican candidates. What he said was totally uncalled for, she hasn't even been buried yet and typical HIM he has to speak from his horses A$$ mouth so badly about her. Vote anything but republican...

        • 1 vote
        Reply#57 - Tue Feb 14, 2012 5:03 PM EST

        Bill O'reilly I hope that the republicans fault you for their downfall. If they don't, then they should

          Reply#58 - Tue Feb 14, 2012 5:20 PM EST

          i'd rather listen to the 99% , then kiss the bee -hinds of the 1%

          • 1 vote
          Reply#59 - Wed Feb 15, 2012 6:59 AM EST

          OBAMA/BIDEN 2012!!!!!!!!

          • 1 vote
          Reply#60 - Wed Feb 15, 2012 8:10 PM EST
          Jump to discussion page: 1 2 3
          You're in Easy Mode. If you prefer, you can use XHTML Mode instead.
          As a new user, you may notice a few temporary content restrictions. Click here for more info.