Requiem for a campaign: Rick Perry's rise and fall

Jim Lo Scalzo / EPA

Rick Perry waits to greet Iowans at the Santa Maria Vineyard and Winery in Carroll, Iowa, Jan. 2, 2012.

 

CHARLESTON, SC -- It was in a cramped Myrtle Beach coffee shop, just hours before the debate that would prove to be his last, when Rick Perry swallowed hard, looked at his wife Anita, and peered into his political future. 

"If I just had to walk away from all this," the governor said, his voice catching on a lump of exhaustion that seemed to have been growing in his throat for days, "If she was walking with me, it'd all be okay." 

To the focus group of mothers gathered in the room, the moment was a touching expression of the couple's love in the face of adversity. But longtime followers of Perry saw something else too: the first real glimmer of the undefeated Texan's understanding that his once-mighty presidential campaign was finally in the last ungraceful throes of its death. 

Two days later, Perry would be peering at the menu board at a Charleston-area Wendy's restaurant and telling top communications aide Ray Sullivan that he'd be ending his five month campaign in the morning.  The press conference was held in a nondescript airport hotel meeting room ... just 14 miles from where he launched his campaign in the glitzy Francis Marion ballroom.

"Now the journey leads us back to Texas," he declared after he suspended his campaign. "Neither discouraged nor disenchanted, but instead rewarded for the experience and resolute to remain in the arena and in the service of a great nation." 

Mark Lambie / El Paso Times via AP

A look at the Texas governor's bid for the Republican presidential nomination.


In his farewell remarks
, Perry thanked advisors Nelson Warfield and Mari Will -- both relative newcomers to his team after an October shakeup that resulted in a deep divide between the governor's old guard and fresh blood. 

Unnamed by the governor in his thank-yous to staff and key endorsers were de-facto campaign chief Joe Allbaugh, onetime manager Rob Johnson, and Perry's original political maestro and friend of 13 years, Dave Carney. 

 

***** 

Everything was going pretty much as planned until Orlando. 

A month after Perry swaggered into the GOP race, a steady stream of fundraisers (which filled up the candidate's schedule at the expense of fulfilling even a fraction of the interview requests that flooded in to Austin) meant that the campaign's war chest was in the same league as Mitt Romney's, the frontrunner in the campaign until that point.

Perry seemed to be aptly navigating away from the Bible-thumping caricature from opponents who snarked about his "calling from God" to run for president and his "praying for rain" in the face of devastating drought. Michele Bachmann's damaging attack over Perry's support for an HPV vaccine for young girls had been substantially blunted by her self-inflicted wound the next day when she overstated the side effects of the medication. 

But after Perry's indignant comment at a Sept. 22 debate that those who opposed offering in-state tuition for the children of illegal immigrants "don't have a heart," the ascendant governor's momentum was abruptly knocked off course by a lower-than-expected finish in the Presidency 5 straw poll. 

After the loss, spokesman Mark Miner grimly marched into the press area and spun the results as a loss for Romney, surprising reporters used to a cagey press operation that frequently ignored email requests for responses or interviews. But little more was done to mitigate the damage. A full six days later, during an interview with conservative web site Newsmax, Perry finally apologized for the "heartless" comment. 

The night of the P5 loss, Alec Baldwin lampooned Perry as sleepy and disoriented during the season premier of NBC's Saturday Night Live.

The Perry parody, which would go through several iterations before settling on "just plain dumb," was born. 

 

*****

In Orlando, Carney and Johnson met with former Dole aide Nelson Warfield, the strategist who would later be the chief advocate of a controversial television ad taking aim at gay soldiers. Carney brought on Warfield and Washington-based pollster Tony Fabrizio to augment a team swiftly recognizing the consequences of Perry's late entry into the presidential contest. 

"At the end of the day, this thing needed to have started two months before it did," said Perry's South Carolina chair Katon Dawson, who along with Carney and Johnson had defected from Gingrich's flagging campaign in June. 

During the CNBC debate, GOP presidential candidate Rick Perry is unable to remember one of the three government agencies he would eliminate if he were elected to the White House.

At the urging of first lady Anita Perry, Texan strategist Joe Allbaugh also began to help advise the campaign. Allbaugh, George W. Bush's former campaign manager, was preceded by a reputation for steadiness, experience and no-nonsense discipline. 

With the arrival of new talent, a reboot appeared possible. The new team --  including Fabrizio, Warfield and media strategist Curt Anderson  -- instituted a rigorous interview and TV ad schedule for the candidate.

When Perry's utterance of "oops" during CNBC's Michigan debate forever entered the political lexicon on Nov. 7, the campaign responded with an unprecedented swiftness -- ushering the self-deprecating candidate to confront reporters in the debate spin room and scheduling light-hearted media appearances to blunt the damage.

But as Carney and Allbaugh's conflicting visions clashed, communication between the two camps disintegrated. Longtime Texas aides began to be cut out of major discussions. On at least one occasion, Allbaugh chose to meet with consultants at the Steven F. Austin hotel -- across the street from the campaign headquarters on Congress Avenue. 

As Perry publicly insisted to reporters that rumors of campaign manager Rob Johnson's demotion were "just scuttlebutt," the Arkansas native was being dispatched far away from the Austin headquarters to work in early campaign states. Carney was sequestered in New Hampshire. 

The famed "vault" -- the thick-walled box in the center of Perry HQ that had served as Carney and Johnson's office -- stood empty. 

Perry's poll numbers continued their decline, and some of the new class of consultants began to grumble to reporters about the after-effects of early disorganization on the part of Carney and his original team. Longtime Perry loyalists fumed at damaging leaks that went undisciplined by Allbaugh or by the candidate himself. 

"There was a misguided sense from the Washington consultants that the simple-minded Texans messed everything up and they were going to rise to the rescue," said Sullivan. "And it didn't work out that way."

The governor's performances continued to be uneven, with Perry alternating between energetically sharp and distractedly rambling even at consecutive campaign appearances. The staff was sometimes left wondering which version of their candidate would show up on a given day. 

And "oops" haunted him. While advisers later determined that the famed "brain freeze" might have been surmountable were it not for Perry's "heartless" debacle, the narrative cake -- unhelped by Perry's Bush-like drawl and his infirm grasp on issues outside his economic expertise as governor -- was already baked.  Errors big and small were amplified into "yet another oops." 

In New Hampshire, when Perry inaccurately pegged the voting age at 21, the moment launched hundreds of headlines. In Iowa, when Perry misspoke in naming "the country Solyndra" (which he'd correctly identified as a solar energy *company* at scores of campaign events before), observers questioned whether he was aware it was not in fact a sovereign nation.  In South Carolina, Sullivan and traveling spokesman Mark Miner bewilderedly fielded calls from reporters who read in an Los Angeles Times dispatch that Perry had mistaken a mannequin for a human person at a town hall. (He was joking.) 

Every bumble -- real or imagined -- had its cost. 

 

*****

If Perry's endorsement of Newt Gingrich last Thursday served as the funeral ceremony for his campaign, the wake came 16 days earlier when his fifth place finish in the Iowa caucuses appeared to snuff out the last flicker of his staff's hopes for salvaging their dreams of 1600 Pennsylvania Ave. 

Early December polling indicated a fluid race in Iowa, where Perry had assembled a formidable team and "strike force" operation made up largely of Texas allies. Albeit often in small venues, the campaign still packed in Iowans willing to give Perry a "second look." His debate performances improved, and an unforced error from Romney offering Perry a bet of $10,000 during a Des Moines debate underscored Perry's populist message. 

In the days before launching his 44-stop bus tour in the state, the Texas governor painted the picture of a new man, blaming his early stumbles on pain resulting from his June back surgery, toppling months of denials from Perry's press staff that the operation had any impact on his performances. 

"Frankly I didn't know the impact it was having on me from the standpoint of just being fatigued and it showed up in the first few debates," he said on Sean Hannity's radio program on Jan. 13. "I have never felt better and I think you saw a glimpse of what you can expect out of me as we go forward in that last debate we had in Iowa." 

Again, hope glimmered, but not for long. 

Two weeks before the caucuses, influential conservatives at the Family Leader seemed on the verge of throwing their support behind Perry.

Senior staff in Iowa heard rumblings of the potentially game-changing endorsement from the group on the evening before the Dec. 20 press conference. But the group ultimately declined formal support of any candidate, and its chief members independently boosted Rick Santorum instead. 

Crowds shrunk. After the Christmas holiday, Perry took on Santorum's previous support for earmarks in his most direct negative ad yet, but the slam didn't seem to stick. 

On the morning of Dec. 31, an anonymously sourced story in POLITICO finally aired in spectacular fashion the grievances of the new class of Perry advisers, who eviscerated Carney and Johnson as inept in handling the media and unprepared for the immigration onslaught. 

GOP presidential candidate Rick Perry gets tongue-tied during a recent interview over the name of Supreme Court Justice Sonia Sotomayor. NBC's Carrie Dann reports.

The sting of the story -- particularly burning because of its publication days before the caucuses -- went uncontested by Austin, with the only voice in response being some tempered on-the-record pushback from Sullivan. (Carney, who was only briefly quoted, had long been detached from the campaign.) 

The Texans, concerned about derailing their famously micromanagement-averse boss with internal distractions, never confronted Perry about the story. Defeat was already all but written, in any case. 
They slogged on. 

After Perry announced that he would "reassess" his campaign after the disappointing caucus night finish three days later, Perry's top Texas aides walked out of the ballroom and into the bar at the West Des Moines Sheraton expecting a dropout press conference in Austin within 48 hours. 

As staffers and surrogates mingled until last call in the hotel's Waterfall Grille Restaurant & Lounge - and bartenders scurried into the bar's reserves for extra tequila for the Texans -- they spoke about the campaign in the past tense, and disdain for the Washington consultants flowed as readily as the drinks. (Allbaugh and others had long since retreated to their rooms.)

At one point, journalists still filing their stories in the lobby heard a cheer so deafening that a few sprinted to see what they assumed must be a guest appearance by the governor himself.

It wasn't Perry, but Johnson. Still beloved by the Austin footsoldiers, he offered a rousing speech to his exhausted and relieved team, sporting a navy blue Perry for President fleece -- a gift from the staff -- personalized with just one word: "Hefe." 

The next morning, he -- along with Miner and the rest of the press staff as well as the lead advance men who would be charged with orchestrating the South Carolina Alamo -- found out from the governor's Twitter account that the campaign wasn't over yet. 

****** 

The night of the Iowa loss, Perry gathered with family and his close advisers in a hotel suite to discuss his path forward.  
Backer and close family friend Capt. Dan Moran, a former Marine who suffered severe burns to over half his body after an IED attack in 2006, was in the room.

Evan Vucci / AP

Republican presidential candidate Texas Gov. Rick Perry gets ready for an interview during a caucus night watch party Tuesday, Jan. 3, 2012, in West Des Moines, Iowa.

With Perry's wife and son Griffin on board to continue the campaign, Moran -- whose fierce admiration for the governor had been on display during a series of fiery speeches to Iowa voters that week -- alluded to his own physical struggle in voicing his support for a last-ditch effort to rescue the campaign. 

"Sir, I didn't get these scars on my face to quit," he told the governor. 

By announcing the next morning that he would continue his presidential run into South Carolina, Perry earned a collective "wait, what?" from the political world and from most of his own campaign team. Moran was one of the few who wasn't surprised by the decision. 

With a roiling field and resistance to an "inevitable" Romney nomination, Perry could have been in a position to catch a late wave in the Palmetto State. But even his allies in the state conceded that Perry needed a "lucky break" to begin courting back the social conservatives and veterans most ideologically aligned with his platform. And he'd have to do it with fewer resources, less vocal endorsers, and a badly damaged political brand. 

Gone was the shiny "Faith, Jobs, and Freedom" bus that had schlepped Perry to over 40 cities in Iowa. Gone were the national political backers who loyally stood by his side before the caucuses, as press staff gradually stopped pretending that former advocates Govs. Bobby Jindal or Sam Brownback would be in the state on Perry's behalf. 

And his final gamble backfired. According to aides, it was Perry himself who coined the phrase "vulture capitalism" to describe Romney's practices at investment firm Bain capital.  

But the phrase disappeared from the candidate's vernacular within two days after some Perry backers publicly rebuked him. Previously supportive conservative commentators on FOX News accused him of leaning towards socialism, reducing the creator of over one million jobs in Texas to claiming he is the "probably the most pro-capitalist individual... in America."

"I think that FOX News jumped on us put us back on the mat again," said Dawson. "When they hit us and they stayed on us for a day we fell back again from the little bit of momentum we created by skipping New Hampshire."

Gingrich, who had employed the same line of attack against Romney's Bain days, was ascendant. Perry's poll numbers in the state that was once his conservative firewall dipped below five percent.  

Late in the afternoon on Jan. 18, Perry began informing advisors that he would drop out the following day.

 

***** 

 

Twenty-four hours before telling Sullivan about his decision under the fluorescent lights of a fast-food joint, the governor was praying. 

On stage at a prayer rally in Greenville, S.C., inspired by "The Response" event he masterminded in Texas last summer, Perry delivered remarks almost word-for-word to those he had given before that audience of 30,000 in a football stadium in August, at a time when history-making drought conditions had prompted the governor to urge citizens to pray for rain.

The Texas governor's decision comes after a disappointing campaign and just days before the critical South Carolina primary, NBC News' Carrie Dann reports.

"His agenda’s not a political agenda," Perry said of God to several hundred worshippers -- a crowd tiny in comparison to the August audience packed into the home of the Houston Texans.  "He’s smarter than that. He’s smart enough, wise enough not to get involved with any political affiliation or any institution that man has made. He understands the imperfections of those." 

Sudden rumbling thunder shook the building as he spoke from Psalms 145 of a God who is slow to anger, and Perry raised his right arm to declare "Amen" in answer. 

As the governor left the stage, he was crying. And smiling. 

It was pouring in Greenville.

 

Carrie Dann (or as the candidate nicknamed her, "Lieutenant Dann") covered the Perry campaign as an embedded reporter for NBC News. Explore more of her Decision 2012 work here.

Discuss this post

Jump to discussion page: 1 2 3 4 ... 6

Perry, along with the remaining Republican candidates for president, is a walking example of the American Taliban.

  • 4 votes
Reply#26 - Wed Jan 25, 2012 6:45 PM EST

It's a shame... I was hoping he would go all the way, and pick our Kansas gov. Brownback for vice president. That away we could have got him out of our state and on the campaign trail, before he set our state back another hundred years.

  • 5 votes
Reply#27 - Wed Jan 25, 2012 6:46 PM EST

He did more to anger those of us who don't share his belief system by excluding us when he talked of faith. Rick Santorum is the same way. Remember his big rally last year, where the only people he wanted to show up were those who believed as he did, no Jews, Muslims, Hindus, etc., allowed? By that point, he made it clear that he was going to pander to the irreligious wrong to the detriment of a large group of potential voters.

The fact that he wouldn't even acknowledge the fact that gays have served honorably in the military (as a matter of fact, the first Marine injured by an IED in the Fertile Crescent is gay) didn't exactly endear him to a lot of people, who now realize that gays are contributing part of society.

One more thing I'll say now: neither party had a candidate who will be able to fix all the problems the country has now. We don't have anyone decent running, and I'm including President Obama in this. He's not much better.

I could go on, but I'll stop here.

  • 2 votes
Reply#28 - Wed Jan 25, 2012 6:47 PM EST

The rise and fall of Rick Perry is due to one thing: viagra.

  • 1 vote
Reply#29 - Wed Jan 25, 2012 6:47 PM EST

"Now the journey leads us back to Texas," he declared after he suspended his campaign. "Neither discouraged nor disenchanted, but instead rewarded for the experience and resolute to remain in the arena and in the service of a great nation."

Perry is a *Born Again* Baptist Christian Conservative of the extreme right-wing Guns & Bibles sect ... so he's *entitled* to wish you a Christian-conservative family-values Merry Christmas & Happy New Year one moment, then the next moment wage Right-Wing Christian Jihadism on all you infidels ...

Problem is, God was horrified by Bush ( and Bush wasn't even a Texan, he's a Kennebunkport elitiist who moved to Crawford, put on a cowboy hat, sang baptist-christian hymns and conned you into believing he was a good'ol boy ) ... and now Perry ... and said to hell with it and took it out on Texas ... as exemplified when God brought months and months of drought down on Texas suspiciously at about the time Perry was considering a Prez-run (and a nuclear-waste facility to be built on an aquifer for millions of people) ...

... then God proceeded to burn Texas to the ground when Perry invited Right-Wing hate-mongers as * false prophets* to a Day of Prayer followed by God turning away a major tropical storm that would have quenched the Texas fire holocaust when Perry announced his 2012 Prez run ...

Take your dumb-hillbilly azz back to Texas Perry, before God wraths on all of us ... besides, your wacko-buddies are doing a heck-of-a-job with this insanity called the 2012 GOP / Tea Bag Prez hopefuls ...

Jus'damn ... LOL.

  • 5 votes
Reply#30 - Wed Jan 25, 2012 6:48 PM EST

Don't blame it on the Baptists - there are plenty of us Southern Baptists that do not believe any of this garbage. For the most part I know very few Baptists in my church who support Perry or many of the tea baggers, we spend most of our time helping and ministering to everyone regardless of their affiliations.

    #30.1 - Thu Jan 26, 2012 5:33 PM EST
    Reply

    Well, Just like I have said for YEARS and YEARS Perry is as dumb as a box of dirt. He is one undeserving dude. He could ONLY be Governor in Texas. We have the WEAKEST Governor's office in the COUNTRY and that is a fact. Texas Miracle you say???? There IS none. The state is $27 BILLION in the HOLE!!! WE are FIRST in everything that COSTS and dead LAST in everything that pays. I have not had health insurance since 1987. I am 60 years old and very sick but NO health insurance. If you call having a minimum wage job at Wally World a "Miracle" then I guess we have one. Otherwise this state SUCKS. Bob Burnitt Ellis County Texas

    • 3 votes
    Reply#31 - Wed Jan 25, 2012 6:48 PM EST

    "Neither discouraged or disenchanted, but instead rewarded for the experience and resolute to remain in the arena and in the service of a great nation. TRANSLATION; "I don't got nowhere else to go."

    • 2 votes
    Reply#32 - Wed Jan 25, 2012 6:50 PM EST

    guess God really doesnt talk to him afterall.this kind of idiocy goes over great in texas but the rest of us have sense, and are fed up with politicians from texas.look at the mess the last fool got us in, we're still trying to get out of it.

    • 2 votes
    Reply#33 - Wed Jan 25, 2012 6:55 PM EST

    My thought is that someone else is going to enter the field before very long: Daniels, Christie or Jeb Bush. The Republican Party is in disarray right now, no matter who wins Florida.

      Reply#34 - Wed Jan 25, 2012 6:56 PM EST

      There will be no other Bush as President . You can take that to the bank .

      • 2 votes
      #34.1 - Wed Jan 25, 2012 9:14 PM EST
      Reply

      Maybe if Kinkey Freidman (TX,comedian,author and silent backer of the Governor) campaigned for Perry, he would still be a viable contender.

      • 1 vote
      Reply#35 - Wed Jan 25, 2012 6:56 PM EST

      Act Two.

      After the pathetic teapublican rubes lose this Nov., I'm sure they'll be looking forward to 2016, ready, with a whole host of equally plastic, hollow caricatures of real human beings ready to assume the mantle of right wing purity, and righteousness.

      Telling us how, America can once again be great,.. if only,... if only, we give the rich, more,.. faster..

      • 1 vote
      Reply#36 - Wed Jan 25, 2012 6:56 PM EST

      I truly think that even Perry was too dumb for the Conservatives....anyone who can make GW look like a semi-intelligent guy has definitely got a problem......I don't know what it is with the GOP and the absolutely insane candidates they support.....

      • 2 votes
      Reply#37 - Wed Jan 25, 2012 6:58 PM EST

      He rose because the republican party is desperate for a viable candidate and hasn't found one yet. He fell because even they realized he is too dumb to be a viable candidate. Hard to imagine someone less appealing than Newt and Mitt, but there you have it.

      • 2 votes
      Reply#38 - Wed Jan 25, 2012 7:02 PM EST

      Seriously?

      I'd like to say that I was able to help make it happen. So, I guess I will.

        Reply#39 - Wed Jan 25, 2012 7:04 PM EST

        I was not aware that Mr. Perry ever "rose." As soon as he started talking about his campaign for the presidency, anyone with half a brain realized that not only is he inappropriate for the job of President of The United States, we also wonder how he could possibly be functioning as the Governor of Texas.

        Whoever decided that it would be a good idea for Mr. Perry to run for president inadvertently did a good thing by alerting the citizens of Texas about the psychological and intellectual state of their current governor.

        • 3 votes
        Reply#40 - Wed Jan 25, 2012 7:10 PM EST

        You mean he was still in...?

          Reply#41 - Wed Jan 25, 2012 7:15 PM EST

          You tell them @Bob! I'm SO SICK of these liberals and their Christian bashing! If Perry were a colored or a gay person they would love him. But because he isn't an elite they laugh at him. Because he didn't go to Harvard they make fun of how he talks. I'm so sick of it.

          We don't need another person with big fancy words as President. We need a leader and Rick Perry has leadership written all over him. It's a shame that the elite media picked on him because he's a white Christian southerner. White men in this country are the most disrespected group I think this country has ever seen.

          • 1 vote
          Reply#42 - Wed Jan 25, 2012 7:17 PM EST

          " ... White men in this country are the most disrespected group I think this country has ever seen. ... "

          Speaking as one of the group that you just commented about, a "white man", I have a theory about why that is true. It's really is a simple theory. So should be easily understood by all.

          The reason that we, "white men" in America, ARE the most disrespected MINORITY, is because of people like you James. And of course I can't leave out Bob. Yep good old Bob. Oh and Rick. You have earned us, the "white male" American, that distinction with your words and deeds.

          So set back and reap the rewards of being the ignorant, bigoted, self-rightous, gun carrying, Bible toting/thumping, hate filled, fear mongering, lieing "white Christian southerner" that you are. You have worked hard at/for it and deserve it. So please enjoy the fruits of your labor.

          And thank you for taking the rest of us, "white male" Americans, down with you. And I really mean it. THANK YOU.

          Now to those of you who are male, Southerner or not, white or not. And who are NOT like James and Bob. I wish to apologize to you, if I have offended you at all. I ment no disrespect to you. And I hope you can forgive me if I did. Thank you.

          To those of you who are like James and Bob? Get over yourself!

          • 3 votes
          #42.1 - Wed Jan 25, 2012 8:37 PM EST

          WE do not need a religious nut job for President either . I was raised in that cult called baptist . The bottom line is Send Your Money .

          • 3 votes
          #42.2 - Wed Jan 25, 2012 9:19 PM EST
          Reply

          Rick Perry is just more proof that there are some really dumb a** white men in Texas....still! But he knows how to hate an kill negros. He was taught by some of the best....gotta give him that. It really goes to show what type of climate still prevails in Texas so far as race. If by chance racism in America ever dies....Texas is where it will be buried. When I think of Texas, I am proud to be from Mississippi. Texans are very proud of rick perry.

          • 1 vote
          Reply#43 - Wed Jan 25, 2012 7:21 PM EST

          Allow me to edit your article: Rick Perry is a championship idiot. No one outside of Texas knew this until they heard him speak. Then it was all over. The end.

          • 2 votes
          Reply#44 - Wed Jan 25, 2012 7:21 PM EST

          Rick Perry is just more proof that there are some really dumb a** white men in Texas....still! But he knows how to hate an kill negros. He was taught by some of the best....gotta give him that. It really goes to show what type of climate still prevails in Texas so far as race. If by chance racism in America ever dies....Texas is where it will be buried. When I think of Texas, I am proud to be from Mississippi. Texans are very proud of rick perry.

          • 1 vote
          Reply#45 - Wed Jan 25, 2012 7:22 PM EST

          Allow me to edit your article: Rick Perry is a championship idiot. No one outside of Texas knew this until they heard him speak. Then it was all over. The end.

          • 2 votes
          Reply#46 - Wed Jan 25, 2012 7:22 PM EST

          Rick Perry is just more proof that there are some really dumb a** white men in Texas....still! But he knows how to hate an kill negros. He was taught by some of the best....gotta give him that. It really goes to show what type of climate still prevails in Texas so far as race. If by chance racism in America ever dies....Texas  is where it will be buried. When I think of Texas, I am proud to be from Mississippi. Texans are very proud of rick perry.

            Reply#47 - Wed Jan 25, 2012 7:22 PM EST

            Where is tall he media coverage on Ron Paul?

            The corrupt Washington establishment, the status quo is well represented by Obama and the Republican Poster Boys' Romney, Gingrich, and Santorum.

              Reply#48 - Wed Jan 25, 2012 7:22 PM EST

              Ww want media coverage for Ron Paul?

              The corrupt Washington establishment, the status quo is well represented by Obama and the Republican Poster Boys' Romney, Gingrich, and Santorum.

                Reply#49 - Wed Jan 25, 2012 7:23 PM EST

                Domingo,

                You couldn't even correctly spell two attempts at asking the same question you asked on the last page of this blog. I'll give you the comment I left for you there again here: Where it belongs, Domingo, covering the remaining candidates with a chance to win the nomination. But don't fret; given his predilections, if he lives past 80, he can trot his ego and his silly ideas before the public for the third (fourth?) time in 2016.

                But since you're so insistent, here's the full story of why Ron Paul should not be nominated for or elected as President. At the very least, Paul allowed his name to be used by racists in his employ to publish racist rants like "Given the inefficiencies of what D.C. laughingly calls the 'criminal justice system,' I think we can safely assume that 95 percent of the black males in that city are semi-criminal or entirely criminal." Paul has no problem banning abortions, which bans were outlawed by Rowe v. Wade, but just thinks it's a state's job to do so because of his warped view of the 10th Amendment. Paul has stated that because he delivered 4000 babies, he knows that life begins at conception (this is as stupid a statement as he's ever uttered--when life begins has been, is, and will always be a question for philosophers or politicians, and certainly not some quirky physician who delivered babies when he was in the Army).

                Ron Paul is a also global warming flip-flopper and now a global warming denier. In 2008, he had this to say about global warming: "It is clear that the earth experiences natural cycles in temperature. However, science shows that human activity probably does play a role in stimulating the current fluctuations. By 2009, Paul was singing a different tune: "The greatest hoax I think that has been around for many, many years if not hundreds of years, has been this hoax on [...] global warming." Even if Ron isn't being paid off by Big Oil, he's still doing their bidding. The concept that humans cause global warming is shared by the vast majority of legitimate climatologists in the world; only scientists hired by Big Oil promulgate the myth that global warming is a hoax or is not caused by human activities. Moreover, his claim that global warming has been a hoax for hundreds of years is so obviously wrong: concerns about global warming have not existed for "hundreds of years." I was around (as were you) for the first "Earth Day" in 1970, and global warming or climate change wasn't an issue then. I'd say it became a topic of discussion about 15 years ago. Paul's statement about there being a global warming hoax for hundreds of years is patently ridiculous.

                However, the most frightening aspect of this dogmatic old fart's belief system is his conviction that we are a Christian nation. According to Ron, "The Founding Fathers envisioned a robustly Christian yet religiously tolerant America, with churches serving as vital institutions that would eclipse the state in importance." This is demonstrably wrong, according to no less an authority than the United States Supreme Court, which has consistently recognized that the purpose of the Establishment Clause of the First Amendment was to build or erect a wall separating Church and State, according to Thomas Jefferson, whose group crafted the clause:

                "[A]t the first session of the first Congress the amendment now under consideration was proposed with others by Mr. Madison. It met the views of the advocates of religious freedom, and was adopted. Mr. Jefferson afterwards, in reply to an address to him by a committee of the Danbury Baptist Association (8 id. 113), took occasion to say: 'Believing with you that religion is a matter which lies solely between man and his God; that he owes account to none other for his faith or his worship; that the legislative powers of the government reach actions only, and not opinions,-I contemplate with sovereign reverence that act of the whole American people which declared that their legislature should 'make no law respecting an establishment of religion or prohibiting the free exercise thereof,' thus building a wall of separation between church and State. Adhering to this expression of the supreme will of the nation in behalf of the rights of conscience, I shall see with sincere satisfaction the progress of those sentiments which tend to restore man to all his natural rights, convinced he has no natural right in opposition to his social duties.' Coming as this does from an acknowledged leader of the advocates of the measure, it may be accepted almost as an authoritative declaration of the scope and effect of the amendment thus secured." Reynolds v. United States, 98 U.S. 145, 164 (1878).
                "Neither a state nor the Federal Government can, openly or secretly, participate in the affairs of any religious organizations or groups and vice versa. "In the words of Jefferson, the clause against establishment of religion by law was intended to erect 'a wall of separation between Church and State.'" Everson v. Board of Education, 330 U.S. 1, 16, citing Reynolds v. United States, supra, 98 U.S. at page 164.

                "This Court first reviewed a challenge to state law under the Establishment Clause in Everson v. Board of Ed. of Ewing, 330 U.S. 1, 67 S.Ct. 504, 91 L. Ed. 711 (1947).1 Relying on the history of the Clause, and the Court's prior analysis, Justice Black outlined the considerations that have become the touchstone of Establishment Clause jurisprudence: Neither a State nor the Federal Government can pass laws which aid one religion, aid all religions, or prefer one religion over another. Neither a State nor the Federal Government, openly or secretly, can participate in the affairs of any religious organization and vice versa.2 "In the words of Jefferson, the clause against establishment of religion by law was intended to erect 'a wall of separation between church and State.' "Everson, 330 U.S., at 16, 67 S.Ct., at 511 (quoting Reynolds v. United States, 98 U.S. 145, 164, 25 L. Ed. 244 (1878)). The dissenters agreed: "The Amendment's purpose ... was to create a complete and permanent separation of the spheres of religious activity and civil authority by comprehensively forbidding every form of public aid or support for religion." 330 U.S., at 31–32, 67 S.Ct., at 519–520 (Rutledge, J., dissenting, joined by Frankfurter, Jackson, and Burton, JJ.); accord, Lee v. Weisman, 505 US 577, 599-600 (1992).

                So what does Paul say about these court decisions: "Through perverse court decisions and years of cultural indoctrination, the elitist, secular Left has managed to convince many in our nation that religion must be driven from public view. The justification is always that someone, somewhere, might possibly be offended or feel uncomfortable living in the midst of a largely Christian society, so all must yield to the fragile sensibilities of the few. The ultimate goal of the anti-religious elites is to transform America into a completely secular nation, a nation that is legally and culturally biased against Christianity." So this arrogant twit, who is not educated in law, purports to be a higher legal authority on what the Founding Fathers intended by the religious clauses in the First Amendment than the Supreme Court, the final authority on what the Constitution means, has consistently ruled since 1878.

                Just because Paul wants to dismantle the federal government, as you want, and will allow you to smoke pot (unless the states continue to outlaw it) doesn't make him a fit candidate for President of the United States. His brand of government may have worked in the 19th Century, but certainly not in the 21st. He keeps being rejected by the electorate because too many of his ideas are just plain kooky.

                Michael L. Marowitz
                J.D., J.S.M. (Master's Degree in Law with emphasis on constitutional law, Stanford Law School, 1981)

                • 4 votes
                #49.1 - Wed Jan 25, 2012 8:30 PM EST
                Reply

                Perry was a fool to think he could run for President of the United States. Bush did it because his old man had been president and people bought it to little george and Rove's bull crap. Gore actually won the 2000 election by over 100,000 votes but little george brother jeb who was governor of Florida at the time stole and lied along with K Harris to give little george the election. Perry who even talked about secedding from the United States which was bull with his 15,000 defense contractors and all the military bases in the state of Texas. Perry has a good record for jobs thanks to those military bases and defense contractors. (Make money off of war) Perry don't go away mad just go away and hide before the real truth comes out on you and your corruption that is bound to be exsposed.

                • 2 votes
                Reply#50 - Wed Jan 25, 2012 7:25 PM EST
                Jump to discussion page: 1 2 3 4 ... 6
                You're in Easy Mode. If you prefer, you can use XHTML Mode instead.
                As a new user, you may notice a few temporary content restrictions. Click here for more info.