After previously scheduling a procedural vote for this morning, the Senate has again pushed back a vote to take up legislation to allow a path to U.S. citizenship for some foreign-born young adults who came to the country illegally as children.
Instead, Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid called a vote at the last minute to “table” or kill the Senate version of the vote Thursday, with the intention of taking up the House version of similar legislation later this month. That motion passed, setting the bill aside.
The bill narrowly passed the House last night, 216-198, but Democrats face a difficult challenge to overcome a GOP filibuster in the Senate. A similar test vote in the Senate in September failed 52-44. (Democrats need 60 votes to move the legislation forward.)
The DREAM (Development, Relief, and Education for Alien Minors) Act would allow those with a high school diploma or a GED to apply for conditional U.S. status if they are under the age of 30 and arrived the U.S. before the age of 16. After a long process -- including two years of service in the military or enrollment in college -- they would then be eligible to apply for legal immigrant status.
Republican critics call the measure “amnesty.” Speaking on the Senate floor earlier this week, GOP Sen. Jeff Sessions of Alabama branded the bill “an immediate reward for the illegal entry, and there is no serious plan to stop the illegal flow—indeed, the legislation incentivizes it.” Sessions notes that the bill would allow some illegal immigrants with criminal records to gain citizenship and that it would offer job and educational opportunities not available to citizens who have always followed the law. “In short, this bill would be a disaster,” he said.
But many Democrats say that the law would be good for the country as a whole. In a statement after the bill passed the House, President Barack Obama called it “the right thing for the United States of America” as well as for “talented young people who seek to serve a country they know as their own.”
“The rule of law must be conditioned by justice and fairness and compassion,” said Rep. Luis Gutierrez of Illinois, the chairman of the Congressional Hispanic Caucus’s task force on immigration and a key backer of the DREAM act. He urged his colleagues to change current immigration rules that are “unfair” to young foreign-born adults living in this country.
Despite its challenges in the upper chamber, the debate on the DREAM Act allows Democrats to vocally back a proposal favored by a fast-growing block of Hispanic voters. Last year, census data showed that number of Hispanic voters surged 28 percent between the 2004 and 2008 election. Barack Obama won two-thirds of Latino voters in the 2008 election.


Supporters of the Dream Act keep on perpetuating this lie that tax dollars will not support illegal immigrant education. The fact is, our tax dollars WILL go to supporting their education. Most of the illegals who will apply for the Dream Act and go to college, will attend PUBLIC colleges/universities. Tuition at public colleges/universities are subsidized by TAX DOLLARS. That is a fact. Therefore, illegals will get their tuition subsidized by our tax dollars.
As for federal aid, the illegal students WILL be eligble for federal loans. These loans have very limited funds and since most illegal students' parents are here illegally, they claim little or no income. Therefore, the illegal students will "out" qualify legal students for these federal loans.
Poor, 'minority', and first in the family to attend college. Of course they will qualify for loans, grants, and scholarships that equally qualified and needy American citizen students will not. People are forgetting that American citizen isn't code for just 'white people' -- American citizens are Hispanic, Asian, Native American, African American, all cultures-- all competing for college funding and admission spots with Dream Act illegals.
Perhaps a better solution is an option for these high achieving illegal immigrant students to acquire an American citizen 'sponsor' - who will provide financial assistance/low interest loans for the illegal to attend college - upon completion of a 4-year degree (or 6 years of honorable Military service), THEN they have earned citizenship. If they go into a field like Medical, where there is a need in our border counties (as well as rural communties in the midwest), they might earn citizenship faster by agreeing to (upon finishing med or nursing school) to working (for pay) in those areas that struggle to get Doctors and nurses. Just a thought....
No Amnesty and while were at it lets send Manny down south.He seems to kick the US too much