Liberals, conservatives and those in between express condolences for the passing of Sen. Robert Byrd. Some examine various aspects of his legacy, both positive and negative, while others speculate on the fate of his now-vacant Senate seat.
Hot Air’s Ed Morrissey commented on the future of Byrd’s seat, as well as his long and varied Senate career. Regarding the political atmosphere surrounding Democratic Gov. Joe Manchin’s chosen successor for the seat, he wrote, “Manchin, reportedly wanted a shot at the seat himself when Byrd left the Senate. That would be a difficult maneuver now, at least in terms of the interim appointment. Had Byrd died a week later, Manchin could have appointed himself to what would have been a two-year term and hoped to ride Barack Obama’s coattails, such as they will be, into a full term in 2012. Now the election will have to be held this year in a midterm cycle poisonous to Democrats, especially in coal country while the Senate attempts to revive cap-and-trade.”
On Byrd’s legacy, Morrissey noted some sordid aspects of his early days in Congress: “Byrd’s history as a KKK recruiter and the man who filibustered the Civil Rights Act was routinely cited by Republicans and excused by Democrats. Ironically, he was the last member of the upper chamber from those days. Byrd also attracted controversy as one of the biggest practitioners of pork-barrel politics in Congress, which endeared him to many West Virginia voters but made him the scourge of clean-government and fiscal-responsibility activists. The media treated him with a bit of amnesia regarding the earlier portion of his career, focusing mainly on his self-described expertise on the Constitution and his work as a historian of the Senate.”
Writing at Reason Magazine’s blog Hit & Run, Nick Gillespie called comments about Byrd’s Klan past “a cheap shot because he did apologize for and disown his participation in the group. Better late than never, I suppose, even if it does make you wonder about all those politicians of his generation, even ones from the Deep South, who never felt a need to recruit for the KKK.”
He added that “it's Byrd's status as the Babe Ruth of pork-barrel spending and taxpayer-funded narcissism that is his real legacy and the one we should never forget or forgive. Here lies a man who pushed his home state to build a statue of him in defiance of a rule that such honorees be dead for 50 years.”
NRO’s Jim Geraghty laughed at an attribute of Byrd’s pointed out by Newsweek’s Eleanor Clift: “He kept an ongoing tally of his friends, using his power to convene and adjourn the Senate to accommodate an ally with a fundraiser to attend or, conversely, adjusting the schedule to make opponents think twice about the decision.”
“Aw, what a guy,” Geraghty wrote. “Don’t we all wish we had a buddy who could adjourn one chamber of the legislative branch when we absolutely, positively had to be at a fundraiser that night?”
Liberal blogger John Cole at Balloon Juice wondered about the future of Byrd’s seat: “One of the weird things about West Virginia is that Rockefeller and Byrd loomed so large that there sort of seems to be a vacuum of politicians of any stature on either side of the aisle at the state level. I’d imagine that if Gov. Manchin ran, he would have a very good chance of replacing him, because he is quite popular and connected and seems to fit in with the sensibilities of WV voters. The state has been trending Republican for a while, so I’m sure with the absence of a strong Democratic candidate, no matter who the Republicans run, it would be a toss-up.”
On his specific bets, he wrote, “I actually wouldn’t be surprised to see Mac Warner, the man who lost to [David] McKinley in the Republican race to unseat [Rep. Alan] Mollohan, try to run for the seat. Likewise, I can see [Rep. Shelley Moore] Capito deciding it is time to move up. We’ll see. I just don’t know how this will play out.”
On succession, liberal blog Daily Kos’ David Waldman considered Gov. Manchin’s nominating himself to the seat. “No one relishes the optics of a governor nominating himself for the job. But neither are most people enthralled with the idea of appointing a caretaker to temporarily occupy a seat to which Byrd attached such immense power and influence over in over 50 years in the Senate.”
But appointing a caretaker is exactly what the Washington Monthly’s Steve Benen thinks Manchin will do, given his Senate aspirations: “It’s in his interest, then, not to declare the seat vacant until after Saturday, after which point Manchin can name a placeholder until the 2012 election.”


OUCH, Ali, that seems unnecessarily harsh "...such as they may be..."
a wee bit partisan there? just curious.
This will be a hotbed of speculation no doubt,...but I think the coat tails will rival anything the Repubs think they have in a so called arsenal,...
Byrd kept us in touch with the past. That had its advantages and disadvantages. He served his state well. While he was a KKK recruiter it wasn't all that uncommon in parts of this country for someone to belong to that organization. I am not excusing what he did but we must see our history for its realities regardless how ugly they may be. The fact is he changed with the times and learned from his mistakes.
This is also kind of a sticky business for Manchin but it will all work out in the end. We need to ensure that the seat remains Democratic whatever else happens.
Clara, Hot Air is a partisan site. And for those of you excusing his past because he apologized and tried to make it right decades later (which he deserves credit for), something tells me you wouldn't be as understanding were he a Republican.
Hey, Lizzie:
Why don't you trot out just such a Republican and give me a shot at it? Or maybe you can't find one?
You got me Clara, I don't know of a Republican who was in the Klan. If you read my post, I said he deserved credit for recognizing decades later how wrong he was. But I still would have a tough time defending the man who once uttered the words ' I shall never fight in the armed forces with a Negro by my side... Rather I should die a thousand times, and see Old Glory trampled in the dirt never to rise again, than to see this beloved land of ours become degraded by race mongrels, a throwback to the blackest specimen from the wilds.'
Let me help you out with that one, toots - Jeb Sessions,...yep your boy Jeb didn't get confirmed for Supreme Court justice for just such an alliance. Did he ever apologize? Nope, don't think so. What about David Duke? Didn't he try to 'govern' once until Tim Russert shredded him on Meet the Press, yeah he apologized for being misconstrued. that was the extent of it. Most of the rest of them are as proud of their memberships as they are of their families,...and I am sure they are ever so respectful to all involved, at least when they think the mics are off and no one is listening. Sure you can't think of a single one?
I didn't have to, 'Toots,' you did it for me. Since I've never heard of Jeb Sessions, don't know why you're calling him 'my boy.' And you'd never see me defending him, David Duke, Strom Thurmond, or any other racist, Republican or Democrat. However, that wasn't really my point. My point, if you refer to my first comment that seemed to inexplicably anger you so, was those that are so quick to defend Byrd's actions wouldn't be quite so quick to defend a Republican guilty of the same actions.
Good Lord! The man passed less than 12 hours ago, and he's being sliced, diced and pickled...
For once I would like to see people acting like Americans, not Dem, Rep, White, Black, Christian, Jewish, etc.......... Just Americans....
Unfortunately, that is fairly typical from what I've come to call the 'Obnoxious assclown wing of the Republican Party,' which is generally composed of bloviating media personalities like Limbaugh and those who would want to emulate him in the blogosphere. There was a time when death eliminated partisanship, at least for the length of time it took to honor the lives of those who spent them in the service to the nation... whether we always appreciated the philosophy or ideology in which that service manifested itself.
However, in the eternal war of the bloviators, there is no stone to be left unturned, no opportunity to be left to waste, no points to be left unscored. Any and all who are on the left must be excoriated as the worst liberal, most corrupt, most Stalinistic piece of scum to ever walk the planet and the people of the nation should be rejoicing at their deaths.
That is essentially the reason, no matter how moderate I might be on some issues, that I could never identify as a Republican again. Every time I hear Limbaugh or Hannity or O' Reilly speak, I throw up a little bit in my mouth.